Food aggression is very common in dogs, and you're right in your thinking that using violence against a dog, especially one who's been beaten, will be counter productive. However, you must clearly establish your dominance, in all facets of his life. Fortunately, dogs communicate dominance in many subtle ways. Yes, 'scruffing' a dog is a common way to show dominance, as it imitates the natural corrective action of a bitch with her pups. However, with older dogs, and can have very surprising results, some of which are not desireable, as the dog recognize the inappropriateness of the gesture - dogs that are beyond puppyhood are not scruffed by dominant pack members. When was the last time you saw an adult human get spanked? Same idea here, discipline changes with age.BruceLeeroy said:ok, so you guys seem to know what you're talking about on dogs, give me some advice. the dog in question is a german/shepard rottweiler. he was rescued from a farm where he was beaten and starved. a friends had given him to a farm family to care for because he lived in town and couldn't have a pet. the farm family had their own dogs and excluded the gs/rott in everything including feeding. after 6 months i saw the dog, skin and bones, and with the original owners permission, stole him. yes i'm going to hell. he has been beaten so thoroughly at times that if you raise something in the air near him, newspaper, flyswatter, voice..... he runs and hides.
5 years later, he's a valued member of our family. he is extremely well trained, listens very well, has never shown any kind of aggression toward people whatsoever. the only problem i have is that when he gets fed, he shows some very minor food aggression, very understandable considering his past. he doesn't growl or snap or anything like that, but when i put food in his dish he stands over it protectively and if i put my hand back down near the dish or even IN the dish, he sort of tenses. doesn't growl or anything, but the tensing concerns me as a sign of some moderate food aggression. considering his background i'm suprised it's not alot worse than it is! also if i hold out a hand with a treat for him i have to constantly tell him "easy" or he'll snap it up and nip me in the process!
i know standard food aggression training involves hand feeding... should i do this? one person advised me to grab the dog and shake him and tell him no. i will not do this. if this is the only way i can think of to train a dog, then i'm not fit to own one imo. i understand and aggree wholeheartedly with the idea of the "alpha male" but with cognitive reasoning and opposable thumbs, i think i should be able to accomplish that position without violence.
anyway it's not really a problem, just something i'd like to try and deal with if for no other reason than to have him sure that his food is his and that he doesnt need to protect it. it might be too late for a 5.5 year old dog to learn that though :/
peace
NiteTiger said:Food aggression is very common in dogs, and you're right in your thinking that using violence against a dog, especially one who's been beaten, will be counter productive. However, you must clearly establish your dominance, in all facets of his life. Fortunately, dogs communicate dominance in many subtle ways. Yes, 'scruffing' a dog is a common way to show dominance, as it imitates the natural corrective action of a bitch with her pups. However, with older dogs, and can have very surprising results, some of which are not desireable, as the dog recognize the inappropriateness of the gesture - dogs that are beyond puppyhood are not scruffed by dominant pack members. When was the last time you saw an adult human get spanked? Same idea here, discipline changes with age.
The most common way adult dogs show dominance is through body language. It's time for you to learn to speak dog
Try this: Next time you feed the dog, bring him into the room with the bowl (collar and leash attatched), and put him into a sit/stay, across the room from the bowl. Fill the bowl, but do not allow the dog to break the sit/stay. If he does, immediately stop filling, and take the dog out of the room. Bring him back in, and back into a sit/stay. While the dog maintains the sit/stay, stand over the bowl, shoulders erect, chest out. Stare at the dog, and walk around the bowl, and play with the food. Continue this until the dog assumes a submissive position, or tries to leave the room. This is him acknowledging that yes, you are dominant, and that is YOUR food.
If he tries to approach the food bowl, even in a submissive posture, move yourself between him and the food, always with shoulders back and chest out, staring at him. Do not let him feed until you say so. Once you allow him to feed, stay near the bowl. And when I say near, I mean right on top of it. Remember, you're the pack leader, and this is your food, he's only eating it because you let him. Periodically, move around the bowl, and use your body to force him to move away. Do not talk to him, or pet him. Simply get in his way so he can't get to the food. Then allow him to eat again.
It may seem mean to us, but your dog will love you for it. In the wild, the lesser members of the pack do not feed until the alpha has gotten his feel and allows them to eat. If they try to approach, they will get a swift response from the alpha. You are the alpha in this pack. He eats at your pleasure, period.
He will understand this, it's instinct. He will also appreciate it, because dogs want a strong pack leader. Right now, he's unsure, because you're breaking his rules. He doesn't understand. That's why he tenses - he's confused. He was eating without waiting for permission, and when you approach, he's expecting violence, so he braces for it, because that's what his instinct tells him should happen. By establishing your dominance at the food bowl, and allowing him to feed, he'll understand that all is well in the pack, and he need not fear you - you're a good, strong leader he can trust.
Remember, put away the soft voices, and soothing talk - dog's can't talk, and adults do not croon to each other. Start speaking his language, body language, and tell him that you're a good strong leader.
He'll love you for it.