What's new
  • ICMag with help from Landrace Warden and The Vault is running a NEW contest in November! You can check it here. Prizes are seeds & forum premium access. Come join in!

Seedbay Seed Vendor Survey-Merged

DoobieDuck

Senior Member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
First thing I’m not trying to beat up anyone here. This could be some valuable selling information for seed vendors. I appreciate all the hard work, time, and effort the seed vendors do to bring us seed buyers the quality genetics that they make available. Seed buyers can make their experiences with buying seeds available to the vendors as well as what they would like to see from vendors and post it here.
I think the seed vendors could give us seed buyers a little more information and better images of their products. For a couple years now I have been very disappointed when shopping for seeds. My first purchases were from the vendor web sites like Planet Skunk and others I found on Seed Boutique. I then moved on to buying seeds from Seedbay but found the same lack of attention by seed sellers to list details about their products and good quality images as well. Short descriptions and terrible images is a better way to state my feelings as to what I found.
The strain descriptions are short, many missing simple information such as whether the strain was indicia or sativa? Ancestry was hard to find. Plant growth details almost non-existent? I was amazed these people could sell these products with so little information. I have sold over 2000 items on eBay and would not think of listing an item with a description this incomplete. I looked at a description, on the garden seed website Gurneys.com, of a package of corn seeds that contained 200 seeds for $5.45. It had a 90 word description with a 35 word comments section covering twice the information of any seed listing I found on Seedbay that was 100x the price. A wonderful image of the finished product too!
Then I started looking at the images on Seedbay and the vendor sites. The images displayed on the vendor sites and on Seedbay were so poor I can’t begin to describe them. Some items had no image at all! You would think if a vendor was asking ten bucks a seed they could display a quality image, ….or maybe two? Some images had enlargement links that took you to an image that was worse than the first. There were no macro images. No plant growth images. I went to Jackson Perkins a rose seller website where the flower images were fantastic. I think they are the number one rose seller in the world. If they displayed images of roses like the Seedbay sellers display images of cannabis flowers they would be out of business in a week.
So I conducted a quick survey of 12 random seed Vendor web sites and 12 random Seedbay listings. As a photographer for 40 years I rated the images as poor, good, or very good, and if they had a macro or enlargement. I then graded the enlargements.
I then analyzed the item descriptions for having the following listed: ancestry, stretch, height, yield, flowering days, smoke report, medicinal effects, indicia or sativa, THC, and awards listed. With some seed descriptions it was hard to find this information if at all, and some were very clear on these details. Things such as having a smoke report I had to determine whether or not they were actually giving details as to things such as harshness, effects etc. or just a “sweet line” or sales pitch. This was the most difficult category to analyze.
So here are the results of my survey:
Survey Results 12-03-2006
Vendor Sites 12 surveyed:
5 had no image,
7 had poor images.
Of the 7 that had poor images 2 had good enlargements and 5 had poor enlargements.
All 12 had descriptions.
4 listed ancestry,
1 listed stretch,
4 listed height,
3 listed yield,
All listed flowering days.
3 had a smoke report,
1 listed medicinal effects.
8 listed indicia or sativa, 4 did not!
2 listed THC and 1 listed awards achieved.
All the vendor sites listed a price. The descriptions were short on average. A couple were very long but did not include any growing or smoke report details, just a sales pitch.

Seedbay Items 12 surveyed:
4 had no image at all!
6 had images that were poor with only 2 being good. None were very good, there were no macros or enlargements.
All had a description.
6 listed ancestory.
2 listed stretch.
2 listed height.
1 listed bud size.
All listed flowering days.
3 had a smoke report.
1 listed medicinal effects.
7 listed indicia or sativa.
2 listed THC.
4 listed yield.
None listed awards. The descriptions were short on average. Some listed ancestry but not whether they were indicia or sativa….I guess I should know?
All the vendors and Seedbay items had an indoor or outdoor reference and guess what else? A price$$ .
I also am very aware of the variables in growing cannabis. I recently finished a Sagamartha mystery mix and Head seeds mix grow where I asked those 2 vendors to please identify their strains I was growing. The answers were the same, they could not be sure just looking at the images and my description due to the variables of growing, light, soil, ferts etc. If they were able to smoke, touch, smell it they could be more accurate. So is this why many details are omitted from the seed vendor descriptions? Are they worried we’ll demand our money back if the plant doesn’t reach the height they list in the description?
I think the vendors are now relying on us buyers to sell their products. We list our detailed grow reports and quality images here for everyone to read and see. I have had, quite a few times, a reply to my grow threads stating “thanks Doobieduck, that **** seeds strain looks great, I am going to ad their strain to my next order.”
Seed vendors I’m not trying to throw you into a corporate war like Pepsi and Coke. I have never been dissatisfied with any seeds purchased from the seed vendors …All I’m asking of seed vendors is to give me and my friends a few more details, how tall, stretch, ancestry, sativa or indicia? A quality image or two so we can be more informed about our purchases from you. Step up to the plate and upgrade your descriptions and images. Your websites too! If you can’t operate a digital camera hire me Doobieduck, or someone who can.
Seed buyers, reply to this thread. Let’s let the vendors know what makes us purchase a certain strain? The image,…… the description,….. was it what you read about it here at Cannagraphic? Why don’t we let the vendors know what makes us buy from them. This information may just help the vendors complete a better sales presentation; develop new strains that satisfy their customer’s needs. Thanks all, Merry Christmas……Dr. Duck.

 
G

Guest

thank you for bringing this up! i feel this has been overlooked for a while.....i compare it to this.....would a van full of illegal immigrants complain about their seats? we don't have many options, and we take what we can get. personally i research til my fingers hurt before i spend good $$ on beans, but i don't always come up with sure answers.

is there any way that reputable growers around the boards could provide pics and info to help? at the very least we could get some better pics for the bay/boo. nirvana's sure got some low quality pics to go along with their low prices. :D

:confused: ?????
 

Grat3fulh3ad

The Voice of Reason
Veteran
I posted this in the other copy of this thread...
I agree, to a point...
I always list ancestry...
Stretch and yeild are as variable as the gardens and conditions in which they are grown, in my opinion, they could be 'rated' but not ever quantified...
Effect is subjective... though generalities hold true, subtleties in taste or high are best discovered through multiple test grows and smoke reports...
Whatever opinions a breeder gives about their own product is automaticly suspect, as hype or pitch... thats why I give away so many seeds, hoping people will take the time to give honest and unbiased opinions..
 
G

Guest

Well said Mr. h3ad. It has to be very hard to walk the fine line between promoting your product and hype. If breeders listed tastes, smells, yield etc. then that would only open a greater possiblity of customers complaining that it didnt smell taste or grow like the breeder stated. I think that ancestry, approx. flower time, and price are all that is needed. The rest is up to us the customer to find out through research and by growing them out several times. But you just cant make everyone happy.

Take care

guerilla
 

trichomefarmer

re-loading
Veteran
Good luck with your wishes

But most seed co. are a bunch of cheapos and are trying to make the most with the least amount of exposure.
also many seed co. are just plant porno directors, and often list their seeds for sale without ever having even grown them out, so they never had the chance to photo them. Also often such a mix will come up, which plant do you photograph, to indicate what to expect?

sad but true.
 
Last edited:

Rosy Cheeks

dancin' cheek to cheek
Veteran
I understand what you're saying doobieduck. The Cannabis seed industry has always been a bit of Wild West in marketing, because of it's outlaw nature. A lot of breeders and seed vendors could do a better job of displaying good breeding and cultivating information about their strains. As of now, a lot of strains are sold only with a short, lyrical BS text on how the high will knock your pants off.
I personally do not care much about decent photos of the plant, it's no more worth than a picture of someone in a lonely hearts column. The picture generally shows the top cola of the best growing pheno (in fact, what a good, experienced grower who has dialed in the strain can do with it), it will reveal almost nothing about phenotype and very little about things such as calyx to leaf ratio, etc.

And this is where the pot forums come into the picture. This is where strains are discussed and rated, where growers show the plants in their context, how to cultivate different strains etc. The forums are in fact an independent control organism that protects the buyers/growers from bad suprises, therefore the interest in reading the strain and grow threads carefully.

World Of Seeds is a new breeder/seed bank specialized in landrace strains. This is the kind of information they give on each strain (I took myself the permission to post the strain info on their Afghan Kush, as an example):

Afghan Kush

Sex: Undefined
Way of cropping: Mainly indoor/very good yield outdoor
Race: Pure race obtained from Afgani Kush zone
Genotipe: Almost 100% Indica
High: Less than 1.5 m indoor/ until 2 meters outdoor
Wide: Depending on prune. Some branched without prune
Growing time: Three weeks
Harvest time: 45-55 days indoor/average October outdoor/pollitano
Resistance to mushrooms: Average
Resistance to plague: Depends on the plague
Irrigation tolerancy: High tolerancy to frequent irrigation and fertilization
Yield: Over 400 gr per m2 indoor/ 500 – 600 gr per plant outdoor
Medicinal value: High (for its high content in CBD).Excellent like antiemetic and antispasmodic
Smell: Hashis.
Flavour: Fruitysweet
Effects: Very narcotic, almost devastater


THC Level: 21.6% measured upon the rest of cannabinoids. 7.4% measured upon the rest of organic substances belonging to buds like: aminoacids, sugars, terpenoids, vegetal hormones, and cannabinoids (determined by gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry)
Number of seeds per bag: 10 seeds
Prices of the variety : Undefined

Come from montainous sistem of Hindu Kush (north of Afganistan). Another pure landrace indica Kush, grows wild in the valleys of Armu Darya , river that border with Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. It’s a variety very stable (almost 100% indica) and probably has been the fruit of successives crossbacks between wild varieties Kush since the diferents races Kush, grow nearly itself in a geographic zone relatively reduced.Powerfull, smells like the best afgani hashis,we can consider a very valuable like a medicinal chemiotype.


This is still less information that I want, but hopefully other breeders will stop counting on mouth to ear to sell their stuff and move in this direction.
 
Last edited:

admiralcornport

Active member
Rosy Cheeks said:
Come from montainous sistem of Hindu Kush (north of Afganistan). Another pure landrace indica Kush, grows wild in the valleys of Armu Darya , river that border with Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. It’s a variety very stable (almost 100% indica) and probably has been the fruit of successives crossbacks between wild varieties Kush since the diferents races Kush, grow nearly itself in a geographic zone relatively reduced.Powerfull, smells like the best afgani hashis,we can consider a very valuable like a medicinal chemiotype.[/I]


that is alot of great info, very nicely laid out too! But look at the descriptive paragraph here... They need an editor, or a better translator. My head almost asploded from all the commas.

I do agree it would be nice to get this kind of info with every bean. :dueling:
 

DoobieDuck

Senior Member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
Rosy Cheeks your quote "And this is where the pot forums come into the picture." was one of my points I wanted to get out...wich I think is wonderful! Admiral thanks for the visit, Dr. Duck.
 

DoobieDuck

Senior Member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
Grat3fulh3ad your quote"thats why I give away so many seeds, hoping people will take the time to give honest and unbiased opinions.. " I think this is a great offer buy you and I am a satisfied receipiant of such! Guerilla...I agree with you on the taste and smell information, but "I think that ancestry, approx. flower time, and price are all that is needed" some of these things are the items missing from a lot of descriptions...yes the images too! Thanks guys for the visit, Dr. Duck.
 

DoobieDuck

Senior Member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
Thanks User Name

Thanks User Name

User Name said:
.....i compare it to this.....would a van full of illegal immigrants complain about their seats? we don't have many options, and we take what we can get.
:confused: ?????
But we don't have to take what we get..the breeders are nice people...we can ask for more info and images as I did? Good to see you, Dr. Duck.
 
B

BeAn

At the end of the day...

At the end of the day...

Whether your happy or not with the pack of seeds i:e the buds you grew, the plants growth habits ETC.. its all subjective... everyones different..

and when money is involved people are going to be more picky about the beans... (peeps cant complain about a free gift, so give em away..saves dealing with complaints)


thats why I give away so many seeds, hoping people will take the time to give honest and unbiased opinions..
^^ Respect, thats what im planning to do.

Keep it green! :sasmokin:
 

DoobieDuck

Senior Member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
BeAn your quote "the plants growth habits ETC.. its all subjective... everyones different.. " I think I made it clear I also am aware of this...but..better images and a little more info is not to much to ask for. I received a freebie from H3ad and that was wonderful and a great marketing idea. So would be better images...See Ya...thanks for the visit, Dr. Duck.
 

Elevator Man

Active member
Mentor
Veteran
Doobieduck - I couldn't agree more on this topic - it drives me crazy. There are few excuses for this being an 'underground', 'outlaw' business etc. If they can get it together to breed seeds, then a website is a doddle. And yes, at the prices charged, a little reliable, high-quality information is not only useful, it's nigh-on essential. I would happily provide photos to breeders for catalogs, except I don't grow enough named strains!
The only downside I can see is where a seed company has whizz-bang presentation and promo, but shit seeds, or shit service, but that's whether the forums can come in.

I also work on computers, phototgraphy, occasional web-design etc., and it's often painful to see such shoddily-presented product on a regular basis. Me and my friends wouldn't get much work if we turned them out looking like that...:)

Obviously though translation is a big, big deal, and I always make allowances for that - I recently had to write an email in French, and apparently my recipients were laughing over that one for a week...:)
 

DoobieDuck

Senior Member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
The Elevator man has chimmed in. Your quote "If they can get it together to breed seeds, then a website is a doddle." I also design and host websites....these breeders could use the information in this thread to upgrade thier websites...today...and the images....today....I would return and purchase over and over to a site that had the images and information I'm requesting here. Thanks Elevator, Dr. Duck.
 
H

h g

seedsmans site is informative but not many pics

The Pure: Skunk No. 1 : Mr Nice Shit
Kerala Krush: Indian Skunk
Swazi Safari: Swazi Skunk
The Real McCoy: Hawaiian Skunk
Pot of Gold: Hindu Kush Skunk
Fuma Con Diablos: Skunk Haze
Haze Mist: Indian Haze
Mr Nice Devil: Afghan Skunk
Mr Nice Shark Shock: Peacemaker: Great White Shark
Mr Nice Black Widow: White Widow
Mr Nice Medicine Man: White Rhino
 

Elevator Man

Active member
Mentor
Veteran
Seedsman are a good example of a vendor that appears at least to be making an effort on the presentation/service angle. Some vendors have grower galleries, which is a nice move, but the pics are still often awful.

I'm not a coder, so I'm wary of sites that use a lot of code as I can't edit them! But we're using the open-source kit Joomla! to build my new site, and it's really easy and straightforward, if a little over-specced for my current needs:

http://www.joomla.org/

But for a seed company that needed to update frequently, something like that would rock, as it doesn't need anyone special to update pages - just type in text, add images, page creates itself on demand...:)
 

Grat3fulh3ad

The Voice of Reason
Veteran
No-one really expects their hamburger to look just like the latex burger in the Ad...
No-one expects their bowl of wheaties in milk to look exactly like the bowl of wheaties in white glue on the front of the box...
When I watch the claims for the latest gadget I know that I will never get the same results as the Actor demonstrating the product...

Of course Cannabis seeds should be held to a higher standard, than your everyday ordinary run of the mill advertisment...
There is really no reason to not display a pic that is representitave of the dominant phenotype of a seedline, unless of course a new and untested cross is being offered, which should be clearly listed as untested...
Indica/Sativa should be listed, but biologist can't all agree on the classification of cannabis(for example some state that 'sativas' are just thin leaved indicas, some add a third classification), so Leaving this one out is also understandable. Considering that some elites used in breeding projects have unclear origins, this complicates the issue further...

Just a couple of thoughts I had related to the topic...
 
B

BeAn

No-one really expects their hamburger to look just like the latex burger in the Ad...
No-one expects their bowl of wheaties in milk to look exactly like the bowl of wheaties in white glue on the front of the box...
When I watch the claims for the latest gadget I know that I will never get the same results as the Actor demonstrating the product...


Exactly....


BeAn your quote "the plants growth habits ETC.. its all subjective... everyones different.. " I think I made it clear I also am aware of this...but..better images and a little more info is not to much to ask for. I received a freebie from H3ad and that was wonderful and a great marketing idea. So would be better images...See Ya...thanks for the visit, Dr. Duck.
^^Yeah, i agree... more info. But better pics wouldnt realy help.. If you use Subcool as an example, his breeder pics are great.. but who is to say they are from the pack of seeds you will be buying? (i think he did a grow from a ten pack of vortex and they did turn out well. But then again all his plants are super potent, resinous mosters from planet subcool :rolleyes: )

What we need is grower reports, that is what i search for if im thinking about buying seeds. But there comes a time when say, if you wanted to buy 8K x G13 x 8K there are no reports anywhere.. and the breeder description is 4 words long or somthing.
What to do??? :chin: Sending out plenty of free testers is the best and most honest way to advertise... not to mention good karma..
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top