T
TrichyTrichy
well said!
I know what it is like to be bullied and to be the bully I guess. I mean I didn't just bully anyone without provocation and I'm talking decades ago when I was a young kid so don't hate okay! I got picked on for being a longhair, for being an egghead, all kinds of reasons and probably was on the receiving end far more.
The thing I worry about is that "anti-bullying" laws could be used to control behavior to a stultifying degree. The government should practice anti-bullying within its' policies and set a good example for everyone. It's hypocritical and smacks of totalitarianism.
No one has any idea my feelings on suicide...I could care less what it says beside my name, I am allowed to post just like every other member here until Gypsy says I can't. I don't think I offended either party that was debating.
Originally Posted by Japanfreakier
People who actually know something on the matter of suicide and not just speaking nonsense disagree with you.
Originally Posted by ibjamming
Really? What DO they KNOW? Not much evidently...
Just messing with you...I don't have much faith in the soft sciences. They're more political than anything.
No one has any idea my feelings on suicide...I could care less what it says beside my name, I am allowed to post just like every other member here until Gypsy says I can't. I don't think I offended either party that was debating.
Not sure what point you're trying to make, but at least you are amusing a few...
Hi, I work in mental health care. Im bound by a vow of secrecy so i cant go into too much detail, but i can tell you that i work with severely sick mental patients of all kinds, and that they are security patients. That means that they have a court verdict that says they are a danger either to them selves or to society.
We have a radically different view of human value and personal integrity here then you have, i can tell you that!
Suicide brother, do you know how horrible everything surrounding suicide is? The time before and after, the job for everyone affected by it, how it affects those who has to clean it up and those left behind? Do you know what it feels like to be a family member of a sick and depressed person? Have you lived to see blood and tears, sorrow and fear.. and i mean lived to feel it affect you, the horror of death and pain?
Ive met a lot of people with shocking stories, stories that would turn your gut inside out if you had to sit face to face and talk with these people. I face psychotic people every day i turn up to work, ive been through plenty of physical episodes, thats normal and its something i try to avoid at all costs. Empathy is my greatest weapon of protection even tho we do train self defense at work regularly. I dont even know where to begin to explain this to you, severe depression is something anyone can end up facing in their lifetime, suicide is something that can strike in any family. To have someone there, with you, that tells you that you have a human value and a human dignity, to have a society there that tells you that you belong is the life saver in these situations. But for society to say that we do not care, or even worse, to say good riddance to seeing these people go would be a horrible horrible waste of human resources. Because as japan said, anyone that has been affected by such a horrible thing in their lives as suicide would know that these people are people with value.
My patients are not only a diagnosis, they are also people with amazing talents and gifts, some are musicians with incredible skill, others are genius at technical things or skilled hand crafters.. I have had some fantastic experiences with these people, real gifts and knowledge about the value of life and death has been given to me by them and i am eternally grateful. A family looses a family member to suicide, do you think that father doesnt leave a hole after himself? Do you think these people are worthless, do you think there is no family in despair left after him???? A workplace without one of their skilled workers, or a band without their best guitar player?? Think about this now, do you know about any great artists maybe that has killed themselves or been severely depressed?
Nirvana - Come As You Are: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YyDg9tT0Vw
Kurt Cobain.. Ernest Hemingway.. Hunter S Thompson, just to mention some people off the top of my head that killed themselves.
People have many reasons for committing suicide, some have a chemical imbalance in their body so they get depressed, others has experienced horrible things.. many reasons...
I hear many say that killing yourself is not rational, but for many people, death is not only rational but it is also natural. Taking your own life is a way of taking control of your own life, its rational for people that has never been in control of their life or lost it.
I could go on.. but you really should know better yourself so ill not over-elaborate... this is Arcticsun wishing you good mental health
I like to debate more than most and I value your opinions, however speaking about closing threads or censoring other members is a very sensitive topic; especially with ones that don't hold the power.
I can understand how some members may see your posts as just more than constructive debate when it includes a hint of carrying a stick (I can shut this tread, but here is what I think......)
Some could even think they were being bullied on the internet and shouldn't post an opposing view to the MOD who just threatened use (or reminded the community) of their greater power.
I really wish free speech was more respected in this community.
Morons make me want to kill threads
Geez relax...it wasn't a threat and I didn't close it...freaking hell. So be it. Everyone else can make whatever comments they want, in any forum and it's all a ok. If I make 1 little post in 1 little thread in the Den it gets blown up into something ridiculous. You win. You won't be hearing from me anymore. Apparently you can only post if you don't have some silly tag by your name. Have at it.
VG, you are someone that I never exchanged posts with, and while
I have respect for you as a grower, and a person that gives a lot
of excellent advice on growing cannabis, there are a few things
I would like to comment on in your post, if you don't mind.
This will all be common sense, by the way.
The first, is nobody knows exactly what another person is going
through, and has no way of knowing. In fact, the majority of folks
have a difficult time understanding their own behavior. Most people
I have talked to in my life admitted that they don't know why they
do what they do.
As far as destiny BS, it is a much stronger argument when observed
without opinion, belief, convictions, and other concepts. Just one
example, are you choosing to breathe at this present moment, or
is it simply "happening?" Is everything else in your body "happening"
because you choose something,or is it "happening" and you don't
really know how it's happening?
When we start to observe the world without using our minds, all the
delusions fall away really fast. Is everything "happening" in nature
a "choice" or does it sort of just "happen" similar to how everything
happens inside your body?
...if these things just happen, why is it so far fetched to actually
observe that everything that happens to us as human beings
pretty much happens in the same way? That there is no such
thing as choice or free will, that it is a complete illusion, and
that we are machines that act automatically?
The answer is simple: Ego, i.e. the identifiction with "I, me, my,
mine, etc." I am, my thoughts, my opinions, my beliefs, my
convictions, my body, my this, my that, etc.
Once you take that out of the equation, you will notice that the
truth is that there is only the present moment, and what is
happening in this present moment.
There never has been, and never can be anything else.
And how does this tie up with suicide, simple, the universe decides
what to manifest in each present moment, and some characters
stay in the present moment and some get taken out.
...and it is the director (the universe) that makes these decisions,
and not the characters, just like in any "production."
hi southflorida, thanks for the kind words, i couldnt really detect much in the way of specific questions in your post, so i'll try and comment on what you are saying.
i find the whole idea of choice vs destiny a fascinating question, and love reading the philosophy and science behind it. people like BF Skinner etc really make you think.
my opinion is that we as humans are pretty unique animals in that we can over-ride our instincts and make a choice, and whilst many choices can be predictable and in line with those instincts - that doesnt make them right or excuse them - there is still a choice.
the bodily functions question is a pretty simple one - they dont take conscious thought, so no real choice there whether to breath or not.
removing 'ego' is impossible, like removing someones personality or identity
i find the whole 'universe decides' thing a bit of a cop-out, like absolving ourselves of responsibility for the choices we make.
as for how does it relate to suicide? - my post was a response to your earlier one that seemed to be saying 'hey - it happened that way because the universe blah blah and i felt that this was the wrong way to look at it. going back to the gay kid broadcast on the internet example. his suicide was a tragic choice - bought about by someone else's very bad choice.
the idea that you should kick back and be indifferent to all the terrible things in the world because 'everything happens for a reason' is just letting yourself off the hook imo.
cheers
VG
I can empathize with you and everyone involved...so FIX IT! You CALL yourselves a "science", yet what has changed?
We have the same problems, in the same numbers...even more in some cases. WTF are you guys doing? Not fixing people is the answer.
Talking doesn't fix chemical/electrical imbalances.
I can empathize with you and everyone involved...so FIX IT! You CALL yourselves a "science", yet what has changed? We have the same problems, in the same numbers...even more in some cases. WTF are you guys doing? Not fixing people is the answer.
Im over here in Norway btw, I guess we have some of the same problems here that you do, but not quite as much of them. I think its a lifestyle problem and to a large extent a governmental problem.