What's new
  • ICMag with help from Landrace Warden and The Vault is running a NEW contest in November! You can check it here. Prizes are seeds & forum premium access. Come join in!

...The Greatest Rock Album Ever Made...

flubnutz

stoned agin ...
Veteran
PazVerdeRadical said:
imo, yeah... madonna is not rock, that is crazy...
no shit. i got nothin against her, she made it huge, more power to her ... but no way its rock, period. if its rock, its gotta grind, and USUALLY with the guitar.
 

hoosierdaddy

Active member
ICMag Donor
Veteran
Just my 2cents...I have always felt that Madonna gargles my balls.
Her genre is bubblegum pop, but I hate to give bubblegum a bad name like that, so I call it puke pop. Madonna...queen of the puke pop top 40.
I wouldn't do her with your junk! Sorry, I just can't stand that nasty old hoor.

Also, you can rock some rap, but rap aint rock.
 

oldpink

Un - Retired,
Administrator
Veteran
i'd like to add a late edition to this list

David gilmour has released an album and DVD called Gdansk recorded in Poland
if you havn't heard it yet get it, Echoes is to die for, by far my favorite song taking over from comfortably Numb (now no 2 in my list of all time greats)

Gimour is a living god as far as i'm concerned
 
C

Classyathome

Meatloaf - Bat Out of Hell...

Still gives me chills - 30 years later.
 

oldpink

Un - Retired,
Administrator
Veteran
I recently learned Paradise by the dashboard light by meatloaf on guitar
I'm a big meatloaf fan and always will be the guy is a class act if ever I seen one
 

Snagglepuss

even
ICMag Donor
Veteran
I gotta check out the version you speak of Oldpink .I been going though all the pink floyd albums again,im absolutly stuck on "meddle".Im %100,its my favorite of all their records.Just keep putting it on over and over..Obscured by Clouds is no slouch either.....
 

swishaman

Active member
Tool - Lateralus

I came here to post Tool - Aenima :)

Both are exceptional, and Tool is by far the most talented band to come out in...well, probably since the beginning of rock. Maynards knowledge and incorporation of psychology is amazing[/]. His vocal ability is also top-notch.

With the best Drummer on Earth, an outstanding Bassist with one of the most highly sought after Bass tones.... It's just incredibly hard to hold a candle to Tool.

Very highly recommend the albums Aenima, Lateralus and 10,000 Days. Opiate and Undertow are also fantastic albums, but more, how can I say this? Undeveloped?
:yeahthats
 
S

stoned teacher

Beatles Revolver, Rage Against the Machine self titled first album, The Cars-The cars, Grateful Dead-Grateful Dead (skull n bones) and Live From Mars Hotel, Metallica-Ride the Lightning, Fleetwood Mac-Rumours, Pink Floyd-Wish you Were Here

and I know I must be the only man on earth that is partial to Zeppelin 3 over the others? 1 and 2 rule too...
 

NOKUY

Active member
Veteran
soooooo hard to pik between those 2 metallica albums we all keep bringin up ...."ride the lightning" and "master of puppets".

my 1st intro was to master of puppets, and then to ride the lightning, and i was equally amazed...i chose master because thats what hooked me even tho lightning was older and a just as raw.

...hard to imagine how things would be if cliff burton was still around
 

swishaman

Active member
I'm sure they would have still turned into the crap band they are today.. :p

Jason Newsted was also a very good bassist and he did fit in the band tone and style wise.

It's just that the singer and drummer are all about drama.

That being said, everything that they have ever touched after Black has been a prime example of trash. If it were just Kirk, Jason and another drummer besides Lars...I could probably listen to them, and believe me when I say the music wouldn't be the garbage they've been putting out since the Black album.
 
Last edited:

Clackamas Coot

Active member
Veteran
Happy Trails Quicksilver Messenger Service
To Our Children's Children's Children Moody Blues
Moonflower Carlos Santana
Love, Devotion, Surrender Carlos Santana & the Mahavishnu Orchestra
 

flubnutz

stoned agin ...
Veteran
interesting choices ... for santana, i still love the early stuff, e.g. the first album (name?), "abraxis" ... for john mclaughlin i'd say "the inner mounting flame" ... what was the one with "dance of maya"? for sabbath ... "masters of reality".
 

RandyMarsh

Member
The greatest rock album ever made? Hmmmm..... Go on ahead and guess what I'm thinking. :smile:

~Abbie :joint:

Atom Heart Mother!

But Dark Side is good..... I guess... haha.

I could never single out a floyd album as my favorite. Though I can honestly say the wall isn't it.
 

EddieShoestring

Florist
Veteran
AbbieDoobie The greatest rock album ever made? Hmmmm..... Go on ahead and guess what I'm thinking.

~Abbie

was it something by Van Hallen?

i'm going for Hawkwind~In Search of Space,

it's a great album. Ok-it may not be technically great-but what it lacks in technique it more than makes up for with trippy psychadelic noises.
 

Fingaz2

Member
nice one Eddie, havent heard that one in years,
what about Robin Trower, Bridge of Sighs. it rocks!
or T2, It'll all work out in Boomland. hhaaha. that"ll get you looking. Never heard of them have ya.
Dinosaur Jnr.
The Ruts, Grin & Bear it.
 

High Jinks

Member
Some of you guys are mentioning truly great albums that should never be forgotten, but are pretty far off base when it comes to the general consensus of the "greatest rock album." First off you must round down the whole greatest band category. Because you cant have the greatest rock album without being arguably the greatest rock band. Lets round it down to our six most cited: The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Pink Floyd and Metalica.
The Beatles: Generally, Sgt. Pepper is consitered to be their greatest record, but you could probably write a master's thesis on why any record after 'Help!' is superior.
Led Zeppelin: My vote is on II.
JHE: While "Are you Experienced" is supposed to be the definitive Experience, my money is on either Axis or Ladyland. While Axis gives me a more well rounded record feeling, Ladyland has a larger body of songs which are all amazing. Its sheer size might beat Axis.
Pink Floyd: Clearly, their most influential commercial success was 'darkside;' though I find PF fans who are musicians gravitate towards 'Piper' or 'Meddle.' I happen to like 'Animals' the best, but would never consider it 'the greatest rock album.'
Metalica: Master of Puppets or Ride the Lightning? This one is such a close call I dont even know...
 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top