I do not believe it is a root issue.. I believe it is a combination of too much power of an oscillating fan on the plants all the time, too much light intensity too soon, and over feeding using hot soil with amendments on top of it causing nutrient lockout the chlorosis issue and mag/cal deficienciesChlorosis should be fixed adding more magnesium. But reading your last posts, seeing you measure both pH and EC, I would say overwatering issues. Overwatering can cause the roots to start rotting and stop assimilating nutrients. Both watering too much quantity and too frequently. Do you think that's a possibility?
In any case it looks like some kind of root issue if I had to bet money on it.
Hi, I don`t wanna be THAT guy, but I have to be. You are putting a lot of stuff that isn`t needed at all. You control VPD but have your lights at 18% as if that means something, if you can`t control PPF it is random spray and pray with the amount of CO2 you have there. I don`t want to be mean, don`t take this as bad attitude. Then, you can`t control your EC, as you said, because all the amendments you use on your grow. The portable AC I recommend you to change it for a split, it consumes 1/3 and it is more efficient, so you will save a lot of money there. 500$ humidifier??? You have a lot of options for much, much less money, I bought one in my countr (Argentina, I know, it is different pricing) for less than 30 bucks.But I’m doing something also very wrong correct
I agree with you I am overdoing it with everything from soil amendments to nute amendments nutes in general , confusing things by doing a foliar spray with MAP Epsom water a few times, foliar spray with cal mag a few timesHi, I don`t wanna be THAT guy, but I have to be. You are putting a lot of stuff that isn`t needed at all. You control VPD but have your lights at 18% as if that means something, if you can`t control PPF it is random spray and pray with the amount of CO2 you have there. I don`t want to be mean, don`t take this as bad attitude. Then, you can`t control your EC, as you said, because all the amendments you use on your grow. The portable AC I recommend you to change it for a split, it consumes 1/3 and it is more efficient, so you will save a lot of money there. 500$ humidifier??? You have a lot of options for much, much less money, I bought one in my countr (Argentina, I know, it is different pricing) for less than 30 bucks.
IMHO, you are trying to micromanage things that are simpler than you think, and that make a mess on your growroom. Advices? Try using only peat, only rockwool, only coco coir, and a simple and cheap two parts fertilizer. Control EC, pH, you have CO2, AC, and you check VPD, you will be more than fine. Other than that, it is impossible to know what is happening to your plants with the amount of things you are doing there and everything people can say to you is just guessing.
Hope you are doing good and my opinion isn`t misinterpreted as bad ill. Cheers.
Intake fan now dirextly blowing on cobs this is working MUCH better already tyI have my circulating fan pointed at my cobs not at my plants, and the plants are getting the blow that’s bouncing off the tent walls.
This seems like the best bit of advice given the situation you've described and the way the pics look to me. I see on lower leaves what appears to be light stress which would suggest you had the lights too close or set too strong previously but have managed to correct it other wise it would be on the top leaves as well which says to me the light stressed leaves were the top leaves or at least closer to the top when it happened (the bleached out area lower and on the left side in the pic). Since there is still some form of stress going on it may still be worthwhile to reduce the power on the lights a little more even if you managed to stop the light bleaching. The RH might not be at optimal levels but it doesn't sound so low that it should be causing widespread problems like it appears in the pic. Plus if you redirect the fans so they're not affecting your plants so directly it might even improve. In an indoor grow air movement created by a fan is important but people often make it too strong and point it directly at the plants. In my experience I've never grown with LEDs yet but it's always been better to have the fan blowing more towards the heat source (the light) but at an angle that allows the air movement created by the fans to bounce off the walls and affect the plants indirectly. Plants don't need a lot of movement from air circulation to positively effect their growth. It just needs enough that the leaves slightly dance or flutter in the breeze. So my advice would be to adjust the position of the fan (even if it oscillates) if the fan is at any point blowing directly on the plants and maybe nudge the power on the light slightly lower or raise the light slightly higher. Then give it a few days to see what impact these changes have on the plant. Since you're running the lights 24/7 and can't change that due to circumstances I would say don't mist the plants. In general I advise against misting plants in an indoor grow and most especially during lights on. If you do mist plants, IMHO it's best to do so just before lights out allowing the moisture to evaporate and/or be absorbed by the plant when it's dark so that any moisture on the leaves is gone when the lights come back on. little beads/droplets sitting on leaves under a bright light can begin to act like tiny magnifying glasses and that would tend to undo any benefit achieved by reducing the light's power or moving it further away. I know in nature plants get rained on but in nature plants generally have an opportunity to dry off before the sun comes back out at full strength. In an indoor environment it's not necessarily advisable to completely mimic nature because other factors imitating nature are kind of idealized. Misting plants is okay once in a while at the right time as kind of a treat but if you do it too often the plants come to expect it (get addicted to it) this isn't so much of a factor in the veg stage but misting plants can lead to big problems in the flowering stage so it's best to just not let the plants have any chance to get used to it at all. Kind of like giving sugar to a baby, it's okay once in a blue moon as a treat but you don't want it to become a habit so it's best not to do it at all.
Wow, it is just too much to discuss here... Anyway, I think you should simplify your method, you are confusing terms and environmental parameters, deficiencies, etc. Remember: KISS. What can I say, I wish you good luck, man.I now have my intake directed straight at my LEDs this is controlling temperature much more effectively I’m running a 6” ac infinity t6 fan with a carbon filter for intake running at half speed. Temps stable at 78 humidity much higher with no portable ac.
Exhaust is an 8” inline with carbon filter with multiple turns and a ducting reducer from 8 to 6 and exhausts out a window. I run this on speed 3 all the time.
I think I will try and treat noticeable deficiencies with foliar sprays until I am able to flush these plants in a couple days to get the runoff down to about 300ppm from 1000. I think I’m having nute deficincies because of an uptake problem due to oversaturarion of nutes and salt buildup
I’m seeing visible cal/mag deficincies chlorosis and early stage N deficincies
The hanging height of your leds seem ok. For my soil-plants i have my cobs around 60-70cm above canopy, coco-plants are abit closer to the lights. It all depends on the enviro factors in your room/tent but the plants will tell you pretty fast if the leds are too much for them.I now have my intake directed straight at my LEDs this is controlling temperature much more effectively I’m running a 6” ac infinity t6 fan with a carbon filter for intake running at half speed. Temps stable at 78 humidity much higher with no portable ac.
Exhaust is an 8” inline with carbon filter with multiple turns and a ducting reducer from 8 to 6 and exhausts out a window. I run this on speed 3 all the time.
I think I will try and treat noticeable deficiencies with foliar sprays until I am able to flush these plants in a couple days to get the runoff down to about 300ppm from 1000. I think I’m having nute deficincies because of an uptake problem due to oversaturarion of nutes and salt buildup
I’m seeing visible cal/mag deficincies chlorosis and early stage N deficincies
I agree with you I am overdoing it with everything
I should use just ocean forest with my added perlite and rocks at the bottom; small amount of earthworm castings mychorrizhae small amount of compost mixed in. That’s my best idea.
My problem from the beginning has been soil/nutes too hot.
Since foliar is just a fancy way of saying misting I wouldn't advise this, if your ph is okay your plant should still be getting nutes even if there's an oversaturation of nutes in the soil. Salt buildup doesn't cause nute lock out, ph imbalances do and that in turn causes the salt build up. So if you think you plant's roots are seeing an over saturation of nutes you should just be feeding your plant plain water until the build up works it's way out of the soil. If you know what I'm about to say then forgive me, I don't mean to insult your intelligence I just have no way of knowing your level of knowledge and the suggestion to foliar feed right now would be a newbie mistake. People new to growing often get this idea in their head that if you want big amazing plants you need to force a whole lot of nutrients and everything else you can think of to make the plant grow. That's not how it works, you can't force a plant to grow, you just give it the most ideal environment you can and let it do it's thing. When you're in veg and working with a preload organic mix like Fox Farms you really shouldn't have to give it much of anything but light and water for the first 4-6 weeks.I now have my intake directed straight at my LEDs this is controlling temperature much more effectively I’m running a 6” ac infinity t6 fan with a carbon filter for intake running at half speed. Temps stable at 78 humidity much higher with no portable ac.
Exhaust is an 8” inline with carbon filter with multiple turns and a ducting reducer from 8 to 6 and exhausts out a window. I run this on speed 3 all the time.
I think I will try and treat noticeable deficiencies with foliar sprays until I am able to flush these plants in a couple days to get the runoff down to about 300ppm from 1000. I think I’m having nute deficincies because of an uptake problem due to oversaturarion of nutes and salt buildup
I’m seeing visible cal/mag deficincies chlorosis and early stage N deficincies
I'll take your word for it on the salt build up but as I see it if it gets that bad you've been over feeding things for a while. When I see deficiencies due to nutrient lock out it's usually because the ph is off and it can be quickly resolved with just plain water at the proper ph. I usually check my ph at every feeding/watering and I usually give just plain water during at least one feeding per week so nutrient lock out for any reason doesn't happen to me very often. As for rootballs I only ever deal with that when it's time to up pot because the plant has started to get root bound. When that happens I don't bother to wash anything away, I just pull out the rootball, score it on four sides to help the roots spread out faster in the new pot and plant it into a bigger pot with more soil. Has worked out well for me. I agree on the CO2 but I try to not mention it as people are going to do what they feel they need to do. In my view CO2 supplementation is more for when you're running a pretty good size grow space with a fair number of plants (more then an average personal grow) and there is more of a need to maximize things. If you're just growing a few plants in a tent or small grow room it's really not needed or worth it in my opinion. You can still grow some very impressive plants without CO2 supplementation and if you don't add it then that's one less variable/expense to worry about.Salt buildup can cause a lockout @HempKat
Excess salts with nothing to do, will start bonding together. Forming unavailable salts.
I'm unsure why we can't see the roots. I would be dragging them out and putting the rootballs in buckets of water to massage away anything I could. Believe me when I say I have power-showed my rootballs clean. I see no point carrying on with these as they are. Remove what you dare, and repot. Lowering demands with reasonable lighting, and turn off that damn co2. They can't keep up with that.
What is he supposed to rinse away from the roots?Salt buildup can cause a lockout @HempKat
Excess salts with nothing to do, will start bonding together. Forming unavailable salts.
I'm unsure why we can't see the roots. I would be dragging them out and putting the rootballs in buckets of water to massage away anything I could. Believe me when I say I have power-showed my rootballs clean. I see no point carrying on with these as they are. Remove what you dare, and repot. Lowering demands with reasonable lighting, and turn off that damn co2. They can't keep up with that.
Well in fairness he's the one that said "I think I’m having nute deficincies because of an uptake problem due to oversaturarion of nutes and salt buildup" I don't think that's the problem here though and pretty much all the suggestions you've been making are solid ones he should take to heart.What is he supposed to rinse away from the roots?
You guys talk about salt build up but he’s using organic stuff, and salt build up is an issue with mineral nutes.
Part of the problem right there.Not using my exhaust fan at the moment.
Oh I don't suggest we all start washing off depleted soil. Potting up is the way. I suggest it here, as it looks toxic. The list of stuff being added is lengthy. The guys answer to everything, is more. If we look at post #22 we see his distilled water is 225ppm, or he really did put 4 different things in his foliar spray. One of which is fox farms product to reduce lockouts by cleaning out salts from the medium. A regular part of the feeding scheme, that's not for foliar application. Not for use combined with calmag either I'm guessing. I get the general impression he has bought the entire shop, and should take it all back.I'll take your word for it on the salt build up but as I see it if it gets that bad you've been over feeding things for a while. When I see deficiencies due to nutrient lock out it's usually because the ph is off and it can be quickly resolved with just plain water at the proper ph. I usually check my ph at every feeding/watering and I usually give just plain water during at least one feeding per week so nutrient lock out for any reason doesn't happen to me very often. As for rootballs I only ever deal with that when it's time to up pot because the plant has started to get root bound. When that happens I don't bother to wash anything away, I just pull out the rootball, score it on four sides to help the roots spread out faster in the new pot and plant it into a bigger pot with more soil. Has worked out well for me. I agree on the CO2 but I try to not mention it as people are going to do what they feel they need to do. In my view CO2 supplementation is more for when you're running a pretty good size grow space with a fair number of plants (more then an average personal grow) and there is more of a need to maximize things. If you're just growing a few plants in a tent or small grow room it's really not needed or worth it in my opinion. You can still grow some very impressive plants without CO2 supplementation and if you don't add it then that's one less variable/expense to worry about.