What's new
  • As of today ICMag has his own Discord server. In this Discord server you can chat, talk with eachother, listen to music, share stories and pictures...and much more. Join now and let's grow together! Join ICMag Discord here! More details in this thread here: here.

Off the shelf retail store screw-in LED and CFL bulb comparisons

Trash can

New member
Well number one I'm cheap. And number two I never had this problem years ago when I was using a hundred and fifty watt high pressure sodium set up. I guess the thing I'm going to have to get used to is these off the shelf light LED light bulbs are a lot more powerful than I thought. Because like I said I'm using four 13 and 1/2 watt bulbs and 3 9 watt bulbs . This is half the wattage I used to use with my 150 watt HPS set up many many many years ago. Back in the OG days,yes I'm an OG refugee. Back then with a 150 watt I couldn't get enough light to my plant, and now with LEDs I'm getting too much.I was just so surprised that I was getting 20,000 lux at 24 in above the canopy. I believe the hundred and fifty watt HPS was quoted at 16,000. I'm just going to have to adapt that the off the shelf LEDs are just really powerful. Back then I was happy when I got two and a half ounces from my 150 w HPS light and I should be able to hit two and a half with the LED light that I have.
 

PCBuds

Well-known member
I downloaded a light meter app and I'm getting 50,000 lux in my backyard with the sun barely showing through the clouds.

I does need to be calibrated (which I can't do without a real meter for reference).

I'm surprised how high the reading is considering it's cloudy.

A different app will give you readings above 20,000 lux.

Edit. I'm getting 110,000 lux in full sunshine.
 
Last edited:

f-e

Well-known member
Mentor
Veteran
Trash Can. People are using 2 or 3 of these led lamps per foot, and perhaps 200mm above the canopy. It sounds like you put about 6 lamps within a foot, and positioned them 100mm above the canopy. With this simple comparison, it appears you demanded far too much from your plant.

20k is lame, but plantlets can get their roots out and make a start with that.
40k is workable.
60k is good
Over 60k can trouble some plants.

These numbers are not for everybody. As we put in more light, the demands placed upon us ourselves become greater. At 40k anything in any reasonable compost should be alright. No records broken, but a smoke without much trouble.

With the right environment, you can lay 100k upon them. Just like the mid day sun, which in the wild is generally too much for them. Most plants are not going to respond to much over 80k though.

It's all very hard to measure. Plus we all use different meters, so comparisons are difficult. Each meter tends to work better on certain light types. If we think to hell with it, and spend 1000s on something we expect to be great... It can't get to grips with 660nm. You can keep adding that magic wavelength for cannabis plants, and the fancy meter will barely notice.

This thread starts with a meter that has orange inserts on the casing. It's a common design, still available for about $10. I have one myself. If we all did.. that would really help with comparisons. I believe that sort of meter is primarily measuring green at 555nm. The very middle of the visual spectrum. Most photography meters at this price are said to. So it gives a poor reading under burple leds. Which have little green, but lots of red and blue that we want.


3 100w equivalents per foot once established, at a height of 200mm above the canopy. While getting established, just 2 of them. That works, we have all seen it in this thread.
 

PCBuds

Well-known member
20k is lame, but plantlets can get their roots out and make a start with that.
40k is workable.
60k is good
Over 60k can trouble some plants.
.

I measured my plant and I was getting around 20,000 lux so I screwed in my five-way splitter with two 5000 k and one 3000 k bulb to crank my lux up to 40,000 lux.



I'll screw in another bulb when she gets used to it,



 

Andyo

Active member
Veteran
sylvania osram fire hazard

sylvania osram fire hazard

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-rel...8-led-tubes-due-to-fire-hazard-300132850.html

I also found a report that some sylvania cieling led caused actual fires

I found it when i was looking for led brand name sylvania as i have used sylvania small ceramic metal halides as the showed good spectrum charts .

Im currently using philips 12w led
I had ordered 2 sylvania screw in 10w led,s to test
So i tested them side by side both on same fittings same time
.
I noticed sylvania 10w way hotter to touch than the philips
I had switched them off to unscrew from holder.

More
https://www.osram.us/cb/recall-safety/p001_corporate_recall_led_lighting.jsp
 
Last edited:

Chevy cHaze

Out Of Dankness Cometh Light
ICMag Donor
Veteran
PCBuds,
I don't think this is light bleaching, as a matter of fact I think she's really fine overall.
The few spots could be anything and nothing really.
You can easily spot light bleaching because it looks exactly as what you would imagine if you heard the word light bleaching ;-)
I'm not messing with you, it really does.
Plus it would most likely show up at the newest growth as that's normally closest to the lightsource.



CC
 

PCBuds

Well-known member
PCBuds,
I don't think this is light bleaching, as a matter of fact I think she's really fine overall.
The few spots could be anything and nothing really.
You can easily spot light bleaching because it looks exactly as what you would imagine if you heard the word light bleaching ;-)
I'm not messing with you, it really does.
Plus it would most likely show up at the newest growth as that's normally closest to the lightsource.



CC

Thanks.
I'll just keep an eye open for an overall pale color.
I'll aim for dark green.
 

3snowboards

Active member
Tk x sfv og
Flowering d7
picture.php
 

PCBuds

Well-known member
My next plant in her new home.
Seed germinated August 1st.

I'm going for the "vertical sog" method again.





My last plant yielded 5.3 oz.

 

Im'One

Active member
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-rel...8-led-tubes-due-to-fire-hazard-300132850.html

I also found a report that some sylvania cieling led caused actual fires

I found it when i was looking for led brand name sylvania as i have used sylvania small ceramic metal halides as the showed good spectrum charts .

Im currently using philips 12w led
I had ordered 2 sylvania screw in 10w led,s to test
So i tested them side by side both on same fittings same time
.
I noticed sylvania 10w way hotter to touch than the philips
I had switched them off to unscrew from holder.

More
https://www.osram.us/cb/recall-safety/p001_corporate_recall_led_lighting.jsp[/quote


I started with CFLs, bought a couple of LEDs immediately burned my plants...pulled hem up high. I mix the CFLs and LEDs and soft white and daylight bulbs to try to get lots of color spectrum
 

Legalcdn

Well-known member
Swazi gold under 240w screw-in leds. Week 14. 1 plant..supercropped.. Tied to tomotoe cage.. Given megacrop with bud boost nute.. She used 2x2ft area. 1st sativa grown. Not a smelly girl..more floral..sweet..

picture.php
 

Hookahhead

Active member
114w mixed spectrum in a 4.15 sq for space. More info in the “Monkey Shit” link in my signature.

Chopped the tops at 10 weeks.
picture.php


I left the lower buds go and moved the lights closer for another 2 weeks but forgot to take a picture before harvest.
picture.php


Harvest of the tops.
picture.php

picture.php

picture.php
 

Hookahhead

Active member
Lower harvest, lots of nice fat buds hanging there!
picture.php

picture.php

This was my first time flowering under SILs. I’ve already said it a few times, but thanks to everyone who documented their grows in this thread. I’m still amazed by what a few bulbs can put out.
 

The Zientist

Well-known member
Veteran
Impressive work guys.

I arrived to this thread through Terpene's posts and there are plenty of juicy things growing under those SILs.

It's quite cool - and unexpected - how you're managing to get such good results with these cheap-ass lights combos, their output really does add up nicely.

Plus, with impressive energetic efficiency (and as a consequence, all the other resources being better used and managed, less heat output, requiring less extraction, less watering, less space and all that jazz).

Inspiring. A joy to watch. :tiphat:

Kind regards
 
Top