Smoke tests of males have been reported to be inconclusive at best as well.
Most seem to agree that while possible and a source of information, it can just as easily lead to a bad selection as it could to a better/good one.
Even if you go the extra mile like Sam and others and actually reverse the males into females, flower those out and smoke them, it seems to lead to inconclusive results as well.
As annoying as it is, for whatever method to select a male, there will be voices saying "yeah but the result was completely different than expected in my case".
Maybe lab analysis will change this drastically.
I think, but i'm no expert, that there's no difference between males and females other than sex and perhaps a bit of height. But they're about the same when it comes to smell(taste), resin production, potency, type of effect, calyx to leaf ratio etc.Great post Goat, thank you for that!
One thing I would disagree with:
I too like to surf the web and read as many reports as I can and soak up what I can find there BUT
There really isn't that much info on male phenos online. I rarely find threads where people show of their males and give reasoning to their selection etc. ...