My replacement fan isn't much older than the old one that's in place and running; same time frame within a few years of each other.Sounds like a well-thought-out air exchange system you set up. My shop is simply a large room that I partitioned into two rooms: veg and flower. Exterior-grade doors. I then punched through the dividing wall at opposite ends with 8" fans, one in and one out, and very short runs of ducting; just enough to make the veg area light proof. These are filtered through Merv13 12" filters. That's about all there is to my air exchange down there.
Sealed rooms are the way to go in my area for several reasons. I have to run a mini-split and CO2 supplementation, of course. I fill water tanks from elsewhere in the basement, so there is a bit of outside air exchange while that happens, every 3rd day or so.
You're probably better off with your old trusty fan than a new one. So many things are built to fail in a short time now. Always good to have a back up though. Very Alaskan trait there. Murphy is indeed a rat bastard.
Forgot to mention I use hypochlorous acid to clean the rooms, and ran an ozone gennie overnight in there when I had it emptied out.
Otherwise, the old one's functioning fine, though it isn't rated to work with a rheostat the way the unused spare is..
But when I unplug the one that is in use, so folks who are working in the vicinity won't notice the peculiar air configurations there, when I plug it back in, there's sometimes an ever-so-slight, barely telling sort of a whistle to it for a brief time period.
20 years is a long time for a bearing to run more or less around the clock, whether on a motor vehicle, or a fan, or....