Depends on what you want to do...relax in tropical oasis (Jamaica), experience a different culture, food, music (ganja).....
Bud Green Sr. is in the know. Stay away from larger locales, you'll really enjoy the vibe. Had a friend in the Peace Corps in the late 80's reside in Kingston during her stint. She lost some of her hearing from the blaring Reggae. Ha! Really!
OR
New York, (experience the city, then find more rural atmosphere to round it out) chock full of iconic features (Times Square, the TV networks, 9/11 Memorial, Statue of Liberty, etc.)the wharfs, museums, off Broadway plays, street carts, multi-cultural eateries, America's architecture, infamous taxi rides! In rural NY, plenty of fruit stands, orchards, Adirondacks and Catskill mountains. Best of both worlds, if there is such a thing in NY. To experience it once...worthy the $$.
And, depends on $$$ you want to spend.
Recall many telling me about Amsterdam, sidewalks full of dog shit, it smells of urine, pick pocketers deluxe (as with any large metropolitan area). True, but there's so much more! Didn't dissuade me from going there 8 times in 12 yrs.! After a week in Amsterdam, I always enjoyed the beach cities of Zandvoort or Scheveningen.
Consider looking for short stay apartment vs. hotel. You can buy goods at corner markets and cook and better place to relax. That's the only way we travel now. Motel/hotel rooms stifling.
Combo 'deals': hotel/flight isn't always the cheapest.
HAVE FUN wherever you decide!
woo hoo. I cant wait to go. thinks for the info guys.
hmmmmm.......
I've been to Jamaica 3 times, but grew up in NY.
NY for sure but stay across the river on the jersey shore, I just looked @ vacation rentals in Long Branch and found one for $110 per night, rent a car and travel 1 hour north to use the PATH train in Hoboken to cross into Manhattan @ 14th street in a matter of minutes.
Feel like relaxing 1 or 2 days? you're already @ the beach and could still be in NYC every evening still. make it interesting and take a ferry across the Hudson, just make sure you know you'll need to take a train back if you guys are coming in late, that Jersey side ferry depot would need to be along an accessible rail station.
The food:
the pizza is to die for
Nathan's Hot Dogs in Times Square
Gray's Papaya (B'way & 72nd St) or Papaya King (179 E. 86th St.) for great
dogs & cool papaya & other fruit drinks.
6th street between 1st & 2nd Avenues, you'll find no less than 20+ Indian restaurants on that one block.
DON'T miss Churrascaria Plataforma @ 316 W 49th St, it's expensive but worth the jing, Google that name to check out their website. one meal @ Plataforma is worth 10 of the best in Jamaica.
Do you want authentic Jamaican Jerk Chix??? I've got a feeling you'd find it in NYC.
Museums, Hayden Planetarium, Statue of Liberty, 9/11 Memorial, Strawberry Fields in Central Park & the Dakota where John Lennon lived. maybe a thousand other things to see & do.
Yeah Maines Interior is where its at really. All the tourists go to the coast but if you go into the woods of maine...bring "bug dope" haha^Maine is awesome. Moosehead lake is one of my favorite places on earth. Haven't been in a long time.
been all over new York ,,, blah,,,, been to Jamaica 3 times ..always had fun there...nothing special bout new York really.. a few landmarks ......the states around new york are more interesting...niagra falls is overrated but the boat trips are fun...yeehaw.. and fuck the Yankees...sox rule