H
highBabyPie
i have serious doubts about this method. how many people other than the op claim to have used it with favorable results?
-
ICMag with help from Landrace Warden and The Vault is running a NEW contest in November! You can check it here. Prizes are seeds & forum premium access. Come join in!
12/1 lighting--Any truth or banana in the tail pipe?
- Thread starter tokinblackguy
- Start date
i have serious doubts about this method. how many people other than the op claim to have used it with favorable results?
Lowman
Member
Many, many, many people. For many years. It works for most strains. The op did a copy and paste...from the original author. This method has been around for decades.
I've tried it and it reduces stretch completely in my indica dominant strains and almost completely in my sativa dominant.
I personally think it's greatest benefit is for sativa growers.
I saw flowering start far faster in my indica dominant strains, not sure about the sativa ones however I didn't see a reduction in the overall time to harvest and I can't say if yields were any different, they seemed similar.
I have no idea what you are asking with your question but I'll take a guess. Perhaps you mean is it hard on the plants to be vegging 24/0 and then switch to 12/1? I weened them off 24/0 over time so I can't say but one of the side effects was a lot of preflowering in one very indica strain but none of the others.
I don't use 12/1 anymore because I don't have issues with power or heat that others need it for, I was more interested in taming sativas and it worked ideally for that but it was taking too long to veg.
I would definitely consider it in future for unruly sativas, the gas lantern 12/1 routine is ideally suited for them in my experience.
One thing about slow growth though: my lighting is pretty crappy in veg so perhaps with more powerful lights they would veg comparably. Some have said they veg faster under 12/1, none of my strains did.
I think there are a lot of factors that will influence how useful this is to different people but there is absolutely no question it works as advertised on a variety of strains I tried it on and it's a well accepted practice for decades in the commercial flowering businesses.
Blaz3
Member
Nice..thank you...I actually like SOME stretch...usually means more yield overall...so it kinda sucks that the stretch is almsot non existant..
what I emant was...going from veg 24/0..to flowering with this method?Lowering the lighth time every two weeks,etc..not going from veg 24/0 to veg 12/1...
Since you saw flowering faster..wouldnt you say that flower time IS lowered?....
because in veg,it already has pistils,and is on the verge of flowering...
surely this method lowers flowering time??!
what I emant was...going from veg 24/0..to flowering with this method?Lowering the lighth time every two weeks,etc..not going from veg 24/0 to veg 12/1...
Since you saw flowering faster..wouldnt you say that flower time IS lowered?....
because in veg,it already has pistils,and is on the verge of flowering...
surely this method lowers flowering time??!
Great thread.
I'll be giving this a bash at some time. Just a quick question though.
Has anyone experienced any difference in cloning off a plant thats been vegging under 12/1? I've skimmed through all 16 pages but cant see anything there. I like to run 2 rooms. clone from one to the other then back again, running each tent through veg/flower. I do hit the snag of vegging only taking half the time of flowering so this method does appeal to me in the way it slows down grow. Maybe instead of a 4 week veg I could push it out to 5 or 6 and then take clones for the 2nd tent which is heading towards finishing.
I was a little concerned about the build up of flowering hormones in the veg stage and the propensity of the clones to jump strait into flower at the reduction of light. In the past I have found some strains want to throw out some pre flowers on clones even when the mother has none. I've put this down to the drop in light intensity and general confusion. Must be pretty trumatic being plucked away from your mother like that
Has anyone noticed its harder to strike clones or it takes longer using 12/1?
I'll be giving this a bash at some time. Just a quick question though.
Has anyone experienced any difference in cloning off a plant thats been vegging under 12/1? I've skimmed through all 16 pages but cant see anything there. I like to run 2 rooms. clone from one to the other then back again, running each tent through veg/flower. I do hit the snag of vegging only taking half the time of flowering so this method does appeal to me in the way it slows down grow. Maybe instead of a 4 week veg I could push it out to 5 or 6 and then take clones for the 2nd tent which is heading towards finishing.
I was a little concerned about the build up of flowering hormones in the veg stage and the propensity of the clones to jump strait into flower at the reduction of light. In the past I have found some strains want to throw out some pre flowers on clones even when the mother has none. I've put this down to the drop in light intensity and general confusion. Must be pretty trumatic being plucked away from your mother like that
Has anyone noticed its harder to strike clones or it takes longer using 12/1?
de145 said:
"I think there are a lot of factors that will influence how useful this is to different people but there is absolutely no question it works as advertised on a variety of strains I tried it on and it's a well accepted practice for decades in the commercial flowering businesses."
I agree and have said all along that this is not for everyone. It depends on your set up, etc. IME, it doesn't shorten bloom time. Maybe by 2 or3 days? I use it for veg only. I use it to control growth, save energy, cut heat, etc. I use straight 12/12 for bloom. Shorter days will affect yield. Id love to save energy cutting the day length thru bloom, but not at the expense of yield. Possibly, if you are willing to accept less yield, it may shorten bloom time. My guess is that it wouldn't be significantly shorter.
If you are trying to affect stretch, I think you need to transition them from 24/0 to 12/1 for about a month. I don't know for sure. I had little stretch after veg in 12/1 for 4-5 weeks. I'm nearing the end of week 7 at 12/12, and I don't think the bloom period will be shorter on the strains I have previously grown. The yield looks like it will be as good as I could hope for.
The last clone crop I ran, I took cuttings from mothers in 12/1 veg, and put them in my nursery with 18/6. It's possible they took maybe 2 days longer, but I got 90% rooting in coco in about 10 days average. Good luck. -granger
"I think there are a lot of factors that will influence how useful this is to different people but there is absolutely no question it works as advertised on a variety of strains I tried it on and it's a well accepted practice for decades in the commercial flowering businesses."
I agree and have said all along that this is not for everyone. It depends on your set up, etc. IME, it doesn't shorten bloom time. Maybe by 2 or3 days? I use it for veg only. I use it to control growth, save energy, cut heat, etc. I use straight 12/12 for bloom. Shorter days will affect yield. Id love to save energy cutting the day length thru bloom, but not at the expense of yield. Possibly, if you are willing to accept less yield, it may shorten bloom time. My guess is that it wouldn't be significantly shorter.
If you are trying to affect stretch, I think you need to transition them from 24/0 to 12/1 for about a month. I don't know for sure. I had little stretch after veg in 12/1 for 4-5 weeks. I'm nearing the end of week 7 at 12/12, and I don't think the bloom period will be shorter on the strains I have previously grown. The yield looks like it will be as good as I could hope for.
The last clone crop I ran, I took cuttings from mothers in 12/1 veg, and put them in my nursery with 18/6. It's possible they took maybe 2 days longer, but I got 90% rooting in coco in about 10 days average. Good luck. -granger
Lowman
Member
Yes I have used it. No problems other than a couple of indica strains I run didn't like it. I don't find it shortens flowering time. It does seem to reduce stretch. Yields are about the same. I don't know what you mean about going from 24/0....if you mean to veg 24/0 than use the flowering schedule...I'm sure not sure why you would. I hate 24/0 in the first place. I would recommend tapering down your light schedule from 24/0 before flowering...but thats just me.
cheers,
No, none whatsoever in my case. I even rooted the cuttings in the 12/1 veg area.
Why is it everything that's made for people with money troubles only makes them worse?
3
332359
Tagged
cannabinauts,
I'm curing 4 plants I harvested out of 9 in 3 gal AeroBags w/coco80%/perlite20%* under an air cooled 600w HPS. Using a 3x3 stall in a sealed room w/CO2, AC, Dehumidifier. Organic grow using Earth Juice and ACT's.
Trying to stay on top of RootMoFoAphids using, at various times, Insecticide soap drench, Cedarcide PCO Choice drench, multiple drenches with Botanigard, and multiple apps of nematodes. When I went to 12/12, I sprayed foliage with Azasol.
So far, so good. No above ground outbreaks, and RA's seem to be under control. I have no hope of ever being rid of them no matter what I were to use, chems included.
These plants were vegged under 12/1. No nanners so far that I have seen. Yield was excellent, and quality is as good as any I've grown.
I'm curing 1 Big Buddha Cheese grown in coco, 1 BB Chz *grown in potting soil w/ EWC and perlite added, 1 Sensi NL#5xHaze coco, and 1 NL5xHaze grown in the *soil mix. Haven't weighed anything yet, but the soil yield was 1/2 the coco yield, at best. Did the soil-coco side by side to see if quality [taste, odor] was better in soil. Jury's still out.
Still have 1 Delicious Critical Yumbolt freebie with an absolutedly bizarre growth habit [flushing], 1 Delicious Critical Jack Herer freebie, flushing 1 Barney's Vanilla Kush, and will start flush in about a week on 3 Barney's Tangerine Dream [3 different seed].
Summer at 30th parallel only allows me to use one light. Have twice sprayed buds with Actinovate to hopefully prevent botrytis. The Tang Drm have the fattest buds I've grown, so time will tell if disaster is in store. Will update again with pics. -granger
I'm curing 4 plants I harvested out of 9 in 3 gal AeroBags w/coco80%/perlite20%* under an air cooled 600w HPS. Using a 3x3 stall in a sealed room w/CO2, AC, Dehumidifier. Organic grow using Earth Juice and ACT's.
Trying to stay on top of RootMoFoAphids using, at various times, Insecticide soap drench, Cedarcide PCO Choice drench, multiple drenches with Botanigard, and multiple apps of nematodes. When I went to 12/12, I sprayed foliage with Azasol.
So far, so good. No above ground outbreaks, and RA's seem to be under control. I have no hope of ever being rid of them no matter what I were to use, chems included.
These plants were vegged under 12/1. No nanners so far that I have seen. Yield was excellent, and quality is as good as any I've grown.
I'm curing 1 Big Buddha Cheese grown in coco, 1 BB Chz *grown in potting soil w/ EWC and perlite added, 1 Sensi NL#5xHaze coco, and 1 NL5xHaze grown in the *soil mix. Haven't weighed anything yet, but the soil yield was 1/2 the coco yield, at best. Did the soil-coco side by side to see if quality [taste, odor] was better in soil. Jury's still out.
Still have 1 Delicious Critical Yumbolt freebie with an absolutedly bizarre growth habit [flushing], 1 Delicious Critical Jack Herer freebie, flushing 1 Barney's Vanilla Kush, and will start flush in about a week on 3 Barney's Tangerine Dream [3 different seed].
Summer at 30th parallel only allows me to use one light. Have twice sprayed buds with Actinovate to hopefully prevent botrytis. The Tang Drm have the fattest buds I've grown, so time will tell if disaster is in store. Will update again with pics. -granger
Growers,
Summer crop is done. No nanners. Yield is great. The Sensi Northern Lights#5xHaze and the Big Buddha Cheese side by side w/ soil and with coco/perlite show little or no difference in taste, aroma, potency. Massive difference in yield. Sticking with coco. Used 12/1 in veg, straight 12/12 in bloom. Sprayed buds with actinovate at 2-3 weeks into 12/12 and again about week 7-8. No bud rot. Here are a few pics.
This is the keeper of the 3 Barney's Tangerine Dream Fem seed.
Freebie Delicious Critical Jack Herer. A keeper, with great taste, aroma, good yield, potency, and very nice up high, not speedy.
My little buddies. Hard workers.
Summer crop is done. No nanners. Yield is great. The Sensi Northern Lights#5xHaze and the Big Buddha Cheese side by side w/ soil and with coco/perlite show little or no difference in taste, aroma, potency. Massive difference in yield. Sticking with coco. Used 12/1 in veg, straight 12/12 in bloom. Sprayed buds with actinovate at 2-3 weeks into 12/12 and again about week 7-8. No bud rot. Here are a few pics.
This is the keeper of the 3 Barney's Tangerine Dream Fem seed.
Freebie Delicious Critical Jack Herer. A keeper, with great taste, aroma, good yield, potency, and very nice up high, not speedy.
My little buddies. Hard workers.
iampolluted
Active member
i ran 12/1 for a month. my blue dream, and yo mama both started flowering. turned em back to 16/8 and everything went back to veg eventually. got a better stretch from 16/8 than i did 12/1, mainly because it induced flowering. i just wanted branches, not buds.
anything over 13 and i may try it again but never 12/1. my yield will be bigger because it started already, but it was more of a pain in the ass for me to deal with when i did it.
anything over 13 and i may try it again but never 12/1. my yield will be bigger because it started already, but it was more of a pain in the ass for me to deal with when i did it.
more light more buds
more light more buds
https://www.icmag.com/ic/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=358 7537
I tried this method outdoors in a greenhouse, I must say Mr. Hill is right on point with this one... tighter, more resinous, greater yield. Im certainly going to give it a shot on my indoor and see how it plays out. If you are trying to save a buck on electricity then this obviously isnt for you, personally Ill take the trade off in increased yeilds ...
Although I do agree that having a shorter daytime cycle than 18/6 is beneficial for the strains Im running as the plants often look way tired of this rather quickly. Shortening the cycle by 2 hours 16/8 made a huge difference in leaf appearance and overall growth seemed to pick up. For now Im sticking with it, Ill let you know how the increase in light hours for the last weeks of flowering plays out indoors.
more light more buds
https://www.icmag.com/ic/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=358 7537
No, I meant 2 weeks. I mean that by August 10th, under natural daylight hours (no blackbox), most of what we have in there would have been budding for two weeks already. So, subtract two weeks from Aug 10th and stop pulling at that time. 13-14 hours of light makes for an awesome finish - (ie: Hawaiian-style)-T
I tried this method outdoors in a greenhouse, I must say Mr. Hill is right on point with this one... tighter, more resinous, greater yield. Im certainly going to give it a shot on my indoor and see how it plays out. If you are trying to save a buck on electricity then this obviously isnt for you, personally Ill take the trade off in increased yeilds ...
Although I do agree that having a shorter daytime cycle than 18/6 is beneficial for the strains Im running as the plants often look way tired of this rather quickly. Shortening the cycle by 2 hours 16/8 made a huge difference in leaf appearance and overall growth seemed to pick up. For now Im sticking with it, Ill let you know how the increase in light hours for the last weeks of flowering plays out indoors.
sourpickle
New member
I'm very interested in this to control stretch in land race satives. Is there anyone still here using 12/1 mainly for this. If so do you use it alone or in combination with root binding and low N?
