Indeed, Slangheat. Good post.
I have considered the idea of a huge outdoor scrog, covering my entire garden space... pretty sure every serious big plant grower I know has considered it...
However, I take into account the surface area of a fully rounded plant. Lets say at harvest, the plant has a diameter and height of 12 feet. If you were to extend the surface area out, it would cover more than the surface area of a flat garden with 100% coverage.
Another problem is maintaining a huge sea of green floating 6 or 8 feet in the air... if you had some kind of crane that could suspend you over the garden for the daily caterpillar inspection come September... Well rounded plants have space between them for ladders and much of the nug can be tended from the ground.
After building a 1200 sq feet of OD SCROG in my black boxes this year, I had the same fantasies again and decided to do some hard manipulation of a garden of Blue Dream plants to see how they handle themselves compared to ones left alone. The stress of hard training definitely slowed things down compared to plants that were staked well and left alone to grow like xmas trees. I think the ones that we leave alone (except for a single topping) will do the best.
I also think that there is a significant difference in the amount of labor that would be involved in the scrog... not sure... I'd have to crunch it some more.
One more thought is that, outdoors, where the penetration of the sun is so much more intense than indoors,, many giant spheres of green beat a flat surface. The idea of 'even canopy' seems more related to a limited lumen environment with light emanating from a fixed position... In the full sun, the nug from the very bottom skirt of my blue dreams were still huge "top"-like colas.
I do top my plants to encourage more tops at the top... But for the most part, i will be letting my plants grow into the biggest, most stable spheres that they can be. Letting them follow their natural structure seems to be most conducive to living up to their full potential.
I have considered the idea of a huge outdoor scrog, covering my entire garden space... pretty sure every serious big plant grower I know has considered it...
However, I take into account the surface area of a fully rounded plant. Lets say at harvest, the plant has a diameter and height of 12 feet. If you were to extend the surface area out, it would cover more than the surface area of a flat garden with 100% coverage.
Another problem is maintaining a huge sea of green floating 6 or 8 feet in the air... if you had some kind of crane that could suspend you over the garden for the daily caterpillar inspection come September... Well rounded plants have space between them for ladders and much of the nug can be tended from the ground.
After building a 1200 sq feet of OD SCROG in my black boxes this year, I had the same fantasies again and decided to do some hard manipulation of a garden of Blue Dream plants to see how they handle themselves compared to ones left alone. The stress of hard training definitely slowed things down compared to plants that were staked well and left alone to grow like xmas trees. I think the ones that we leave alone (except for a single topping) will do the best.
I also think that there is a significant difference in the amount of labor that would be involved in the scrog... not sure... I'd have to crunch it some more.
One more thought is that, outdoors, where the penetration of the sun is so much more intense than indoors,, many giant spheres of green beat a flat surface. The idea of 'even canopy' seems more related to a limited lumen environment with light emanating from a fixed position... In the full sun, the nug from the very bottom skirt of my blue dreams were still huge "top"-like colas.
I do top my plants to encourage more tops at the top... But for the most part, i will be letting my plants grow into the biggest, most stable spheres that they can be. Letting them follow their natural structure seems to be most conducive to living up to their full potential.