I'm not going to try and post quotes to respond to as there are too many but I will say a few things.
Thank you Hammerhead for admitting being wrong about opiated sticks. That's a class move. Noted and appreciated.
Regarding whether cannabis grown in the north and away from the northeast was potentially used to make opiated sticks. No, just no. While the distance from Isaan does matter in terms of the practical possibility of connecting the opium and the cannabis generally, specifically there were grow syndicates that did do big grows elsewhere at times simply because they had a place available or wanted to find a spot where they had paid off the police or any number reasons. There is ZERO reason to conclude cannabis grown near poppy operations must have been used that way.
There are several reasons it didn't happen. I'll list them as succinctly as I can.
!. The stick producing culture was not an opium growing or using culture.
2. The two drugs simply aren't complimentary. The Thais were fully aware of this.
3. The attitudes and knowledge of western middle class drug users regarding drugs and their uses were completely different from the Thais. Stoners in college dorm rooms in the 70s might have thought it made sense that opium explained the effects of what they smoked but they had no idea what they were about on that. Pure stoner fancy. that's it.
4. As a business move to actually try and do what it would have taken to do it would have been crazy. Lots of effort, much more risk, no significant reward for it. The Thais are not stupid, they know how to do sensible business.
5. There is no proven simple effective reliable method to do it. Especially at scale and with consistent results. Despite all the pondering on vague methods that sound like they might work, the reality is it would be a nightmare and in the end anyone attempting it would end up with a whole lot of previously good cannabis completely ruined. This idea that you would grow it, harvest it, dry and cure it, arrive at a basically finished product AND then soak it in some kind of water solution and then dry it again and it would still be great smoke only better is simply crazy. Any type of process like that would totally ruin it. PERIOD. How would it get dried a second time and not have terrible mold problems? That would be impossible to avoid or even control. Those hardworking farmers were way to smart to do such a dumb thing. It would have added a huge amount of complexity, risk, and time also. They would have needed to arrange and acquire the opium or water or whatever and have it where it was needed at just the right time along with a reliable simple process that village farmers would be willing to do on top of what they already did.
6. In the destination countries busted product would have been tested at times and if opiates were found the authorities would have freaked out. It would no longer be a rumor but well documented in government reports, court cases and news stories. Dealers who got busted would have charged with opiate crimes. It would have been an ongoing highly publicized thing. There would have been college kids showing up at hospital emergency rooms, stoners puking and nodding out at concerts. Problems with stick smokers becoming opiate addicts. NONE of that happened from smoking Thai sticks.
I was around and saw and smoked and sold plenty of Thai sticks. The myth existed then. I heard it many times. We often joked about it. We knew it wasn't true even back then. It's incredible that the myth still lives. It's impossible to kill I guess.
Thank you Hammerhead for admitting being wrong about opiated sticks. That's a class move. Noted and appreciated.
Regarding whether cannabis grown in the north and away from the northeast was potentially used to make opiated sticks. No, just no. While the distance from Isaan does matter in terms of the practical possibility of connecting the opium and the cannabis generally, specifically there were grow syndicates that did do big grows elsewhere at times simply because they had a place available or wanted to find a spot where they had paid off the police or any number reasons. There is ZERO reason to conclude cannabis grown near poppy operations must have been used that way.
There are several reasons it didn't happen. I'll list them as succinctly as I can.
!. The stick producing culture was not an opium growing or using culture.
2. The two drugs simply aren't complimentary. The Thais were fully aware of this.
3. The attitudes and knowledge of western middle class drug users regarding drugs and their uses were completely different from the Thais. Stoners in college dorm rooms in the 70s might have thought it made sense that opium explained the effects of what they smoked but they had no idea what they were about on that. Pure stoner fancy. that's it.
4. As a business move to actually try and do what it would have taken to do it would have been crazy. Lots of effort, much more risk, no significant reward for it. The Thais are not stupid, they know how to do sensible business.
5. There is no proven simple effective reliable method to do it. Especially at scale and with consistent results. Despite all the pondering on vague methods that sound like they might work, the reality is it would be a nightmare and in the end anyone attempting it would end up with a whole lot of previously good cannabis completely ruined. This idea that you would grow it, harvest it, dry and cure it, arrive at a basically finished product AND then soak it in some kind of water solution and then dry it again and it would still be great smoke only better is simply crazy. Any type of process like that would totally ruin it. PERIOD. How would it get dried a second time and not have terrible mold problems? That would be impossible to avoid or even control. Those hardworking farmers were way to smart to do such a dumb thing. It would have added a huge amount of complexity, risk, and time also. They would have needed to arrange and acquire the opium or water or whatever and have it where it was needed at just the right time along with a reliable simple process that village farmers would be willing to do on top of what they already did.
6. In the destination countries busted product would have been tested at times and if opiates were found the authorities would have freaked out. It would no longer be a rumor but well documented in government reports, court cases and news stories. Dealers who got busted would have charged with opiate crimes. It would have been an ongoing highly publicized thing. There would have been college kids showing up at hospital emergency rooms, stoners puking and nodding out at concerts. Problems with stick smokers becoming opiate addicts. NONE of that happened from smoking Thai sticks.
I was around and saw and smoked and sold plenty of Thai sticks. The myth existed then. I heard it many times. We often joked about it. We knew it wasn't true even back then. It's incredible that the myth still lives. It's impossible to kill I guess.