Since you mentioned this being a "theory"............The only thing that jumped out at me is the fact the the sun is FAR more intense than our lights so even though it diminishes in the fall............its still far more intense than what we can create with HIDs. Just a thought.
So in order to reduce the light by 50% you would need the dimmable ballast right?
you ay the sun is far brighter than our grow lights .... even when it hits the earth at 100,000 lumens ..... an air cooled 1k light produces 190,000 lumens at bulb .... and since its cooled it can get up close.
what the sun does have that we can never improve on, is intense canopy penatration
with approx 3 weeks of the cycle left to go the buds have formed all the calyxes they are going to, defining your yield, so by reducing the light you are not reducing your yield.