What's new
  • ICMag with help from Landrace Warden and The Vault is running a NEW contest in November! You can check it here. Prizes are seeds & forum premium access. Come join in!

deodorant poll

deodorant poll

  • I use deodorant that contains Aluminum

    Votes: 10 32.3%
  • I use deodorant that doesn't contain Aluminum

    Votes: 9 29.0%
  • I don't use deodorant at all. Wahooooooooooooooooooo!

    Votes: 12 38.7%

  • Total voters
    31
G

Guest

ha, luckily i was able to achieve that state of mind with a lil weed instead =)
 
G

Guest

i heard on certain raw diet, like fruitarianism..or others... you actually stop smelling totally... ? maybe so
 

genkisan

Cannabrex Formulator
Veteran
Tom's of Maine Honeysuckle deodorant....expensive but good.


The aluminum is in anti-persrpirants...products that are anti-odor only are usually ok...
 

Yummybud

Active member
Veteran
lol I use teh spray on deaodrant like axze or red zone not because those commercials show you getting attacked by crowds of naked women but I'm just lazy and spraying is faster.

plus deodrant doesn't really eliminate the smell when you sweat a lot like when you are working hard or doing sports. You'll just smell like sweat + deodrant.
 

Yummybud

Active member
Veteran
Kirby said:
Vinegar can be used as a deodorant.

lol that's disgusting, vinegar has a strong smell, you'll just smell like vingegar or sour milk to everyone around you.
 
G

Guest

Okay...Okay....check this out.

I read the article at http://www.prweb.com/releases/2005/7/prweb264030.htm Where the nurse, (Andrea Garland, a registered nurse at the Sharon, PA Regional Hospital ) is telling us the evils of deodorant and antiperspirant and how it's making our vital organs toxic and causing cancer.

So I did some research on this. Look up the chemical and it's tests and uses, etc.. All found to be in acceptable ranges. In fact, there tends to be more of it in our drinking water, as it's used to help clean it.

So I went back to the article, which was very convincing. She even suggested an alternative, "Crystal Deodorant Stones" and where to buy it.
the new “crystal deodorant stones”. These stones are 3 times more effective than commercial deodorants, they are not sticky or greasy and do not stain clothing. The crystal deodorant stone does not contain any aluminum or other harsh chemicals, perfumes, oils, emulsifiers, alcohol or propellants and are hypoallergenic.

Although the crystal deodorant stones are still hard to find in local stores, they can be found online. One online resource is www.naturalhealthmarket.com.
Oh, well that was nice of her to even give us a website to go and order some of these hypoallergenic crystal deodorant stones - you know, it's a good idea, this nurse tells us we should - we don't want cancer.

Hey ...hmmm. Let's do a domain whois:

Registrant:
Andrea Garland [email protected] 724-346-9110
Natural Health Marketplace
289 Sunset Blvd
Hermitage,PA,United States 16148


Domain Name:naturalhealthmarket.com
Record last updated at 2006-11-27 21:12:03
Record created on 2003/2/19
Record expired on 2008/2/19
Source: http://www.networksolutions.com/whois/results.jsp?domain=naturalhealthmarket.com

Wait a second - the owner of this online store given to us to prevent the dangers of deodorant is the same Nurse Andrea Garland whom is telling us about how evil deodorant is in the first place and what's with registering a legit business with a hotmail account.

Hmmm, I smell more than B.O. I smell a sales pitch.

Hey, that's fine, all is fair in business right - although I'd trust a business more if the business owner didn't hide behind a free anonymous email like hotmail. After all, if you're running a legit business, you don't need to hide. And I'd trust someone more if being in a medical professional had medical research to back their claims. All I can find is:
There is no scientific evidence supporting widespread rumors that aluminum salts in deodorants can cause Alzheimer's disease or breast cancer. Amongst others, research published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute found no evidence whatsoever that these compounds increase the risk of breast cancer.
I just took that quote from wiki, but I did check a bunch others. Here's one good place to start, they have a list of other links related to the chemical and tests made on it. http://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/sis/search

Anyways, I'm sure there is something to the use of antiperspirants and inhibiting the body from it's natural expulsion of bacteria and other toxins, but thus far the data states the amount in deodorants is less then what you're drinking in a normal glass of tap water.

And me thinks....someone is just trying to sell some crystal deodorant stones to suppliment their nursing salary. But hey, retirement is expensive and I give her an "A" for effort, but a "D" on backing her claims.
 

marx2k

Active member
Veteran
Yummybud said:
lol I use teh spray on deaodrant like axze or red zone not because those commercials show you getting attacked by crowds of naked women but I'm just lazy and spraying is faster.

dude here's a little note... that Axe/Tag shit...smells like shit...the only people who don't think so are the people who actively (over)use it :)

And this isn't directed towards you, Yummy, but people way overuse perfumed shit. Shampoos, soaps, deodorant, hair spray/gel/mousse/etc. If you're like me and you don't use ANY perfumed ANYTHING, walking around these people is about as pleasant as walking through the perfume aisle at the local mall. It SUCKS. I wish people would tone down on that shit.

lol that's disgusting, vinegar has a strong smell, you'll just smell like vingegar or sour milk to everyone around you.

You really only smell the vinegar for the first few minutes. By the time youre out of the bathroom or out of the house, you don't smell it anymore. It works wonders for BO and is a natural way to get rid of it without worrying about poison creeping into your body.
 

Kirby

Member
marx2k said:
dude here's a little note... that Axe/Tag shit...smells like shit...the only people who don't think so are the people who actively (over)use it :)

I like the way their 'Kilo' smells. All the others are trash.
 

Yummybud

Active member
Veteran
lol I'm not one of those guys that empties a can of axe on themselves. I just do a quick spray.

I don't wear cologne, hate being around people that smell like cologn/ perfume, can't breathe around them.llllll
 
G

Guest

That's on ALUMINUM ZIRCONIUM, I narrowed to only checking Aluminum Chlorohydrate, as that's the active ingredient in the one I use.

Anyways...I toss in some excerpts:
Why is aluminum added to drinking water during treatment?

Microorganisms present in drinking water include viruses, bacteria (e.g., E. coli), and protozoa (e.g., Cryptosporidium and the beaver fever causing organism, Giardia). At low levels, these organisms can cause sickness and disease (incl. severe diarrhea) and are generally very difficult to remove from water. The parasites Giardia and Cryptosporidium are very resistant to most types of disinfection, including chlorination. Water treatment with aluminum sulphate is, however, effective at removing these parasites when used in a chemical treatment process called coagulation.

Coagulation is a process in which small particles (0.001 to 10 m) bunch together to form large particles (>10 m), which can then be removed by settling or filtration.

In natural water, most particles (including microorganisms) have a negative electric charge and, rather than clump together to form larger particles, the particles repel each other.

To get the particles in solution to form larger clumps, this negative charge must be neutralized. This can be done by adding positive ions, such as aluminum or ferric ions, which react with the negative particles and form clusters of particles called microflocs. The microfloc then grows and will either settle out or can be filtered out of the water by a treatment system such as sand filtration.

Aluminum sulphate is the most common chemical used for the coagulation of particles. During coagulation, several other undesirable impurities in water are also removed, including naturally occurring organic matter, which reacts with chlorine to form disinfection by-products that may be carcinogenic. Coagulation is an essential step in effective water treatment and, when carried out properly, the residual amount of aluminum in the finished drinking water is small. Other coagulants, such as ferric chloride, are more hazardous to work with. Some coagulation chemicals are organic polymers blended with aluminum- or iron-based products - these are more costly and are generally used only under special circumstances.

How are we exposed to aluminum?

More than 90% of our daily intake of aluminum comes from food, but this aluminum appears to be bound to other substances in the food and cannot be absorbed by the blood stream. In contrast, aluminum in water can be absorbed by humans because after water treatment, the aluminum is largely in an unbound form. Even so, the amount of aluminum absorbed from drinking water is usually very small.

How can aluminum affect my health?

At low levels, aluminum in food, air, and water is not likely harmful to your health. However, at high concentrations there is evidence linking aluminum to effects on the nervous system, with possible connections to several diseases, such as Parkinson's, Alzheimer's, and Lou Gehrig's disease. Patients suffering from these diseases tend to have high levels of aluminum in some areas of their brains. It is not known if aluminum is causing these diseases or if the aluminum starts accumulating in people that already have the diseases. There is also some concern that aluminum may cause skeletal problems. There is no evidence to suggest that aluminum affects reproduction, or that it causes cancer.
Source: http://www.quantumlynx.com/water/vol7no1/story6.html

Here's some information on the absorbion of aluminum in various forms on test animals and human test subjects.
http://rais.ornl.gov/tox/profiles/aluminum.shtml
3.3.1.1. Human
Aluminum compounds are used in antiperspirant products without harmful effects to the skin or other organs. However, some people are unusually sensitive to these products and may develop skin rashes (ATSDR, 1990). Children who had injections of vaccines or allergens in an aluminum-based vehicle showed hypersensitivity to aluminum chloride in a patch test (ATSDR, 1990).
There's more in that, if you're interested. The article suggests problems and toxicity with large amounts - which is like anything on this planet, excessive amounts of anything is very bad.

As for amounts in your drinking water, the ppm amount in drinking water varies to where you are. Here's a generic data sheet on drinking water contaminant levels from Bay County, Florida: http://www.co.bay.fl.us/bccor/2005WaterQuality.pdf
During April 2005, the aluminum test result was 0.39 ppm however, we believe the higher than usual level was the result of the Water Treatment Plant testing the use of Alum in place of Ferric Sulfate as a coagulant. After we discontinued the use of Alum, a retest for aluminum was done in July 2005 with results of 0.046 ppm, well below the MCL. Aluminum is a Secondary Contaminant and as such is not a health concern at low levels.


Now according to OSHA a typical Anti-Perspirant Deodorant Spray (made by Hydrox Laboratories in this example) gives off 15% of Aluminum Chlorohydrate in a given application (based on a 2/08/05 dated test result), which of course varies user to user. You referred to ALUMINIUM ZIRCONIUM, this contains 20% in a given stick of deodorant/antiperspirant. (source: United States Patent 6045823)
So given theses studies, the amount of absorption via topical application (using an aluminum salt based deodorant) vs ingested absorption (the "cleaned" drinking water), the amounts absorbed into the body are significantly higher by the drinking water than by daily use of the deodorant.

Even still absorption is still low according to the International Aluminum Institute (http://www.world-aluminium.org/environment/health/index.html), "recent studies have shown that the absorption of aluminium from the digestive tracts is often as low as 0.001%". And in healthy individuals, the kidneys quickly excrete most of the aluminum our bodies absorb.

The biggest source of aluminum comes from our municipal water supplies. Many municipal water supplies are treated with both aluminum sulfate and aluminum fluoride. And if your water is fluoridated, the situation is even worse. The National Institutes of Environmental Heath Sciences NIEHS ( http://www.mercola.com/2001/may/16/fluoride.htm ) acknowledged that fluoride has been observed to have synergistic effects on the toxicity of aluminum. They found boiling fluoridated tap water in an aluminum pan leached almost 200 parts per million ppm of aluminum into the water in 10 minutes and leaching of up to 600 PPM occurred with prolonged boiling. Using non-fluoridated water showed almost no leaching from aluminum pans. (source:http://www.dld123.com/q&a/index.php?date=2006-04)

There's the horrible results - You get more aluminum from your water than your deodorant. An exact comparison would be better of course, but because of the low absorption rates from topical application (ppm comparison) vs ingestation, there has been no specific studies done except with large amounts (http://rais.ornl.gov/tox/profiles/aluminum.shtml) and those studies found the amounts acceptable due to the body's ability to rid it's self of it - save large amounts which it will absorb into the bones and slowly release to get rid of it. Which makes me wonder, how much aluminum are we carrying around in our bones by drinking soda pop out of cans? And I'm tossing that aluminum pot I have - your bringing up this topic has made me aware of, not so much worried about my deodorant, but how awful that aluminum pot I have is - I do boil in it to cook! It's gone - outta here, damn I had no idea.
 

marx2k

Active member
Veteran
Im so glad I made the right choice and installed a 6 stage RO unit under the sink. As long as it's producing water @ ~10ppm, I don't even want to know what the hell is in the tap water.

The local water utility here is having issues with releasing either too much or too little chlorine into the drinking wells. And then local wells ar egetting shut down due to high levels of manganese as well as VOCs from the old dump sites that are starting to contaminate and permeate the underground city aquifer.

Hell in a handbasket, I tells ya (sipping on some clean, fresh RO water... AHHHHH)
 
Last edited:

lifetime

Member
only antiperspirants have aluminum in them.

i have never used antiperspirant because it just doesn't seem natural to me, even before i knew there was aluminum in them.
 

Pops

Resident pissy old man
Veteran
Ganjalord, I'm pretty sure that I had beaver fever when I was young, but I don't know if it was cured by aluminum in the water or old age.
 
I am in on the earlier post... my dad passed away last year from cancer.

Anyway, while he was sick he obviously did a lot of research. And let me tell you from water to non-stick pans to microwaves... they all are supposed to cause cancer one way or another!!

So I think everything in moderation!
 
Do this many people really not use deodorant? wow. I'm sorry, but there's no fucking way I'm leaving the house without deodorant. I sweat entirely too much at the place I work to get by without it. BO is a HUGE turn-off. I've been around people that I'm pretty sure didn't use any kinda deodorant, and it sure as shit isn't a pleasant experience. That's why they call it 'offensive odor'. You may not smell yourself because you're used to it, but trust me, everyone else can smell your stinkin' ass.
 
Top