Crazy Chester
Well-known member
Attacking the breeder you got your seed from your now reproducing seed of is productive how ?
IMO - it's productive to alert potential seed buyers to the true nature of the seeds - which is valuable information in cases like this where a breeder is misrepresenting the nature and quality of his seeds.
Everyone here recognizes that Brothers Grimm brought Cinderella 99 to the world 20+ years ago and that it was great.
That's the respect Brothers Grimm deserves - but, that's also ancient history - especially for those of us who no longer have our keepers from those old Brothers Grimm seeds.
Speaking for myself, it is not an attack to express one's disappointment at the false representations Mr. Soul has made about the quality of his new Cindy seeds. But, if it is an attack you are perceiving, it is one that is well deserved because "Mr. Soul" released the new version before 1) test growing it; or, 2) after test grows confirmed it is not close enough to share the name of the original version.
If Mr. Soul had been upfront and truthful about how the new Cindy actually compared to the original, there would be nothing to attack - but he wasn't.
It was disrespectful for him to misrepresent the nature and quality of the new Cindy seeds to the very growers who supported him by buying his very expensive seeds 20+ years ago - they were worth the price for the original back then, but we feel like Soul ran the 'ole bait and switch on us by him insisting the new release is "just like" the old one. I think he's even stated that the older growers who popped the original have found that the new one is just as good - talk about disrespect - too many growers who had the real deal back then (like me, Lost Tribe and about a half dozen others who have posted on this thread) are still around to give their comparisons of the new Cindy to the original Cindy.