Verite said:I prefer to mix the truth with a childs imagination. When they ask where Santa is when hes not around for christmas I tell them hes hiding from death and taxes.
I do think its kind of funny to quantify projecting complex adult thoughts and relationships into the mind of a child where they are fairly incapable of understanding the complexity of it.
I suppose there would be alot of problems if kids learned everything they knew from their own parents, fortunately for many they have other external influences.
Verite said:Wow, so when you asked the five year old how he felt he responded with empowered and vindicated? Seems I wasted alot of time on such basic thoughts and emotions like happy and sad at that age.
newbgrow said:... I have since adopted a "no bullshit" philosophy...
resinryder said:When my kids were 4 and 5. a day trip to the zoo sounded like fun. As we got to the cages behind glass that contained some type of monkeys, the male monkey began licking a female monkeys genitals. My 4 yearold daughter, in a crowd of people including the zookeeper, asked loud enough to be heard by all standing there, Daddy, what's that other monkey doing to that one? As I felt that sinking embarrasing red heated feeling engulfing my body and noticed everyone else there was waiting and smiling to see what my answer was, I calmly stated he was eating fleas and grooming her. Grabbed both their hands and proceeded to the next cage. Wish that damn zookeeper had spoken up that day.
Grat3fulH3ad said:I think you underestimate the abilities of childrens' minds... The issue at hand imho is dumbass parents passing their own ignorance to the next generation... I will fully indulge my childs imagination... and I will never respond to a legitimate question with bullshit... My child had enough sense early on to realize there was no santa... when he Asked we questioned him enough to see that he knew, made sure he really wanted the truth, and then told him... We still Play santa, but he knows fully well that it is play and fully enjoys playing it... When he was told the truth, he felt empowered and vindicated, because he had already figured it out... He was 5... and he was told not to tell other kids...
BTW when he asked about my backroom garden I was honest about that too... I trust my son and he trust his parents... He knows that no matter what we will not bullshit him, and he knows how to keep the secret too, because he knows how important it is...
How can it be the wrong thing to encourage our childrens ability to 'figure it out'? How can it be the wrong thing to deal with our kids with honesty? Imagination is to be encouraged, Without a doubt! But is bullshit to be encouraged as well? How about misinformation? My son has a very active imagination... He uses it to solve problems, figure things out, play games, write stories, build with his lego blocks, and alot of other constructive activities... He does not waste it believing in bullshit...