W
Water-
Again: where are the evidences than Neandertales or Devisonias knowed to grow anything?
N so much easy: where are the evidences that we Sapiens growed anything before the Neolitic?
If anybody has any evidence, then we here in Icmag will have the great honor to see the greatest antropologic (n botanic) revolutionary discovery since Darwing.
PD: btw, in my country died the last Neandertal knowed, n we have the most large registre about them...but we have any evidente that they knowed how to grow anything. N here the weather is so much better to farming than Altai.
The neolithic revolution was caused by environmental and population pressure.
farming is hard work compared to hunting
It does not take much intelligence to understand what happens when you plant a wild seed.
And they had larger brains than modern Humans.
https://www.nature.com/news/2010/101018/full/news.2010.549.html
Beginning in the early 2000s, Longo and her colleagues started analysing unwashed stone tools from a 28,000-year-old human settlement in central Italy called Bilancino. Patterns of wear on the sandstone tools suggest that they were used for grinding, like a mortar and pestle. The stones were also coated with several kinds of microscopic starch grains. Longo and her colleagues identified the grains based on their shape as belonging to the root of a species of cattail and the grains of a grass called Brachypodium.
https://www.history.com/news/oldest-bread-grains-jordan
"The charred remains of a 14,500-year-old pita-like flatbread, made from grinding together cereals and tubers, were discovered in a stone fireplace in the Black Desert in Jordan, according to a study published this week in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Though archeologists and historians have long tied the first baking of bread to the advent of agriculture in the Neolithic era, the new find predates that by more than 5,000 years."
keep an open mind.