That is what my light meter says.
If the cost of 1 Horti is $75 (rounded) and the cost of 1 Plantmax is $25...I guess you could replace the Plantmax bulbs every 2 months and still spend the same (assuming the replacement cycle for Horti's are 6 months).
Look at the this graph--
View Image
Notice the decline in both HPS & MH at 1000 hours (83 1/3 days at 12 hours per day). Six months at 12 hours per day equates to 2190 hours.
Bear in mind, as your lumens & PAR decline with hourly usage, your actual electricity usage will remain the same (no discount). So, imo...if I replace my bulbs more often than every 6 months, then the ratio of my lumens to kilowatts should be more efficient. In other words, why spend the same amount in electricity if the amount of lumens/PAR you receive each month is rapidly declining?
Yeah I am aware of the fall offs.
Great timing for this debate; I have an 8 bulb re lamp coming up in two weeks. Horts are at 6months. I am not sure if I will go all plant max.
But I will at a minimum grab a couple and do a side by side test.
About $650 in horts or $184 for plant max.
Now that I think about it switching every two months as you suggested (same cost) would probably way out do the horts. At least in lumens.
I'll need to compare light frequency graphs on both.