What's new

How I Loved Two Good Girls to Death

Did you check your ph when you mixed your feeds? This sad situation is following along the bad ph play book. They start of good in new soil mix. They move along but start having little problems. They stall, get some bug issues and then just start to fade yet keep your hopes up for a turn around. Then about 3/4 the way through flowering they ph issue finally kills them. Root aphids cause this slow death scenario too.
I check pH with each batch of feed and every few days if I happen to have a large volume which is rare. I am generally at around 6 but will lower or raise depending on what I want to push. I totally agree though that pH problems will manifest in very similar ways. That's a big point too, if you don't know and keep a record of what you have been putting in it's hard to do a proper postmortem. I appreciate your input. (y)
 
Last edited:
The drainage theory is not making sense to me. If I put a pot in the ground or line the hole and have drainage holes and you dig a hole and fill with a soil mix our bottoms of the holes have the same unusable native soil. We are both draining into the same substrate. Mine just goes through drainage holes or a cutoff bottom. Yours doesn't.
In very dry areas some people line with a tarp and don't have drainage holes so they keep every drop of water in the hole.
As they say in my country, let me try and split the justice. I may be wrong, but I think you are coming at this from the standpoint of extremely hot and dry conditions where the surrounding soil is relatively dry so it would act as kind of sponge absorbing water from the pot or at least not limiting drainage. On the contrary, I believe @Creeperpark is concerned about a situation where the surrounding soil cannot 'equalize' the water in the pot and it stays too wet because it can't drain optimally. Both points have equal validity based on prevailing conditions in the respective environments.
 

Creeperpark

Well-known member
Mentor
Veteran
No, there's a big difference between sub, and top soils. If you dig down below the topsoil you will hit 1 of 3 horizons. Those horizons are not conducive to plant growth like the top layer. .Some sub soils are almost pure lime and will neutralize any hydrogen the plant needs for nutrient transport. 😎

 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top