-
ICMag with help from Landrace Warden and The Vault is running a NEW contest in November! You can check it here. Prizes are seeds & forum premium access. Come join in!
Between Sun and Moon HPS/LED comparison grow.
- Thread starter hazy
- Start date
seems as if diff strains react differently to the led/hps lighting.... could b interesting to look at in the future... maybe leds bulk slower indicas more than sativas etc... my test will be coming soon... just waiting to crop out my main room before i reconfigure everything
looking clear hazy
looking clear hazy
CurtisLemay
Member
Are LEDs cooler than HPS lights?
right on opt1c!. I know you're going to do it right.
CL said:
Like the difference Between Sun and Moon. You could just recirculate through your filter. No need to vent outside, because there's no heat to get rid of. Could vent out of a box/closet into a room. No losing all that AC to the exhaust vent! No need to cut a hole in an exterior wall or try to vent into the attic etc.
very nice looking grow by the way hazy,regardless of the outcome you did a fine job with this test,the plants all look nice and healthy,and I like the deep color of the led sides leaves!
TexasToker
Member
They sure look 'cooler' !
it is,i unpacked mine today,its gave me a little nerd-gasm...
TexasToker
Member
G
guest5703
Wow what up Hazy???? Been a long time since we last talked, looks like the HPS is winning to be honest eh?? LED is sure doing a kick ass job though! Keep it real Hazy! PEACE
Zealious
Member
lolz @ unc that nerdgazm was lovely. grats at ur new hardware.
To me, seeing the LED get this far is a win for me.. I would gladdy sacrafice 10-20% final weight to get my room cooler. Heck getting my room cooler might increase my yields in the end.
And at half the power consumption. People we are on the verge of revolution.
Haze you mentioned the SD starting to go into its ripe phase on the HPS side.. As we all know this is the best part of the plants life when the plant uses all its sugars and energy and transfers it to the fruit...
I recently read that LEDS of the past have struggled in this phase.. having a hard time tricking the plants to do this.. I believe it had a lot to do with intensity of light and more about spectrum.... but i wonder with the LED sour disels looking so green if this is an example of this.?
Idk could be wrong.. im no expert.. but would like to hear what ledgirl has to say on this.
To me, seeing the LED get this far is a win for me.. I would gladdy sacrafice 10-20% final weight to get my room cooler. Heck getting my room cooler might increase my yields in the end.
And at half the power consumption. People we are on the verge of revolution.
Haze you mentioned the SD starting to go into its ripe phase on the HPS side.. As we all know this is the best part of the plants life when the plant uses all its sugars and energy and transfers it to the fruit...
I recently read that LEDS of the past have struggled in this phase.. having a hard time tricking the plants to do this.. I believe it had a lot to do with intensity of light and more about spectrum.... but i wonder with the LED sour disels looking so green if this is an example of this.?
Idk could be wrong.. im no expert.. but would like to hear what ledgirl has to say on this.
Zealious
Member
OH I just remembered. the ariticle was in maximum yield. You guys should check it out.. Its really good.. I remember in the past MY was stating leds are not a good product to light ur gardens yet.. but when they are we will be there to cover it... they have run a 3 issue long story on leds.
Haze.. I know leds usualy do a better job at like 24" but acording to this article.. when the ripining phaze starts u should drop that led light closer..
but you might want to read the article before u listen to me.
http://www.maximumyield.com/article_sh_db.php?articleID=539&yearVar=2010&issueVar=March
Haze.. I know leds usualy do a better job at like 24" but acording to this article.. when the ripining phaze starts u should drop that led light closer..
but you might want to read the article before u listen to me.
http://www.maximumyield.com/article_sh_db.php?articleID=539&yearVar=2010&issueVar=March
grow2bfree
Member
Great Job, Hazy! Looking forward to your weights and smoke report.
Peace.
Peace.
looking good hazy - very interesting how some of the strains seem pretty equal and the chem 4 is so different - would you say the chem on the LED side is less ripe than the hps?
what im also really interested in is your opinion of the potency. hard to be objective about it but i suspect that the MMG i gew under LED is a bit stronger that when i grew it under hps - certainly it is not lacking at all!
cheers mate
VG.
what im also really interested in is your opinion of the potency. hard to be objective about it but i suspect that the MMG i gew under LED is a bit stronger that when i grew it under hps - certainly it is not lacking at all!
cheers mate
VG.
Day 52 - the chop nears!
Day 52 - the chop nears!
Sour Diesel
hps
led
hps/led
hps/led
-----------------------------
Chem4
hps/led
hps/led
hps/led
------------------
Sugar Shack
hps
led
hps/led
hps/led
hps/led
Day 52 - the chop nears!
VG~ I took 3 chem 4 cuts and one of them grew twice as fast as these two, just after rooting. These two were pretty close till I started this run and flipped them. The hps side Chem4 was a little bigger, then I gave it veg nutes during the stretcg by mistake.May have contributed to it's height.
On the ripening thing I'll look at trichomes tonight and give a report on % cloudy or amber. The Sugar Shack is finishing fast. I'll take it by Saturday. That will be 55 days for it.
I took a pretty good look at the Sour Diesels and I think they both go over 2 ounces. I hope. The hps one may be a bit more, but I'm thinking not as much more as the big buds make it look like. I may give one more feeding of just bloom, then flush till the end.
Ok some pics. Sour Diesel first, then Chem 4 then Sugar Shack. HPS on the left LED on the right. Only got whole plant pics of the SD and not enough budshots of the hps sd.
On the ripening thing I'll look at trichomes tonight and give a report on % cloudy or amber. The Sugar Shack is finishing fast. I'll take it by Saturday. That will be 55 days for it.
I took a pretty good look at the Sour Diesels and I think they both go over 2 ounces. I hope. The hps one may be a bit more, but I'm thinking not as much more as the big buds make it look like. I may give one more feeding of just bloom, then flush till the end.
Ok some pics. Sour Diesel first, then Chem 4 then Sugar Shack. HPS on the left LED on the right. Only got whole plant pics of the SD and not enough budshots of the hps sd.
Sour Diesel
hps
led
-----------------------------
Chem4
------------------
Sugar Shack
hps
led
threeeleven
Active member
Wow great comparison thread!! Amazing amount of information and pics... can't wait to hear dry weights on both sides!
G
guest5703
yea for sure they look awesome, I guess that LED is pretty good for keeping up with the hps though eh?? Right on, looks like it should be some nice SD for you! Big nugs!
