What's new
  • As of today ICMag has his own Discord server. In this Discord server you can chat, talk with eachother, listen to music, share stories and pictures...and much more. Join now and let's grow together! Join ICMag Discord here! More details in this thread here: here.

Advanced Nutrients Versus Botanicare

MMZRetro85

Active member
Hey guys, MMZRetro Here with my first experiment. Iv been wondering about advanced nutrients for a long time, there advertising and marketing got my attention, from seeing them on the show “Weeds” to being all over the Hydroponics industry. So after finding out some information about their product and pretty much how they break everything down so you end up using 3 things to make up one, if that makes any sense. After talking on the phone with the advanced guys over in Canada determining what I would need for a complete cycle, (thanx TM) you know who you are. A week later the complete organic lineup showed up at the doorstep. So let me get down to it, what I wanted to figure out is, is the advanced nutrients all cracked up to be, is it worth how expensive it is.
The advanced line up consists of
Organic B
Piranha
Tarantula
Humic Acid
Voodoo
Iguana Grow
Iguana Bloom
Mother Earth Super Tea Grow
Mother Earth Super Tea Bloom
Big Bud
Sweet leaf
Emerald Shaman
With a total Cost of around 400 dollars
(Not showing Emerald Shamon, Organic B, Mother Earth Super Tea Grow



Since I am familiar with the Botanicare Line up and have had very successful Results with it, I’ve decided to do a side by side cycle of Bontanicare Vs Advanced.
The Botanicare line up consisted of
Liquid Karma
Pro Series Grow
Pro Series Bloom – Soil version
Sweet Citrus
Blast Off
With a total cost of around 150-200 dollars


Now for the good stuff. With this project I have decided on these genetics

Northern Lights
Super Skunk
The ?
Soma’s NYCD

½ of all cuttings were done in treated rock wool, using Olivia’s cloning solution and bcuzz root.
Other ½ of all cuttings were done in groclone using spring water.
All cuttings approximately 13” when put into flowing
Each batch of nutrients of both brands resulted in the same PH and required the same amount of PH up to result in app 6.2PH.
Daytime Temperature – 76f
Nighttime Temperature – 60f
Humidity at 50%

6 cuts of each, which adds up to 24 cuts each side with a total of 48 cuts
This project is done in soil, with 2 1000 watt HPS on 2 light different light rails
With co2 on a 20LB tank and regulator
Ocean Forest Soil by Fox Farm
Promix
Perlite
Pro Series Vegative Grow

Veg for 2 weeks in 1 quart pots with a mixture of Promix, ocean forest, and perlite under 80 watts worth fluorescents 2 inches over the tops. Using a nutrient schedule of, 15ml of Pro Grow per gallon
15ml of liquid karma per gallon.



After 2 weeks repotted into 3 gal containers with a mixture of (1 part ocean forest, and 1 part perlite, on the bottom of the pot) and 1 part promix.
3 scoops of promix on top, with 30ml of pro grow, and 10 ml of liquid karma, and decided to add a little secret ingredient of ¾ tsp Bcuzz Root. Now Flowing
During the weeks of flowing the nutrient schedule consisted of alternate watering.

A: 30ml of bloom (soil)
10ml of Liquid Karma
10ml of sweet citrus

B: 30ml bloom (soil)
10ml of Liquid Karma
10ml of Blast off

Watering was approximately ½ gallon per pot every 3 days
Water supply is well water with a ph of 6.3



Advanced Nutrients

Veg for 2 weeks in 1 quart pots with a mixture of Promix, ocean forest, and perlite under 80 watts worth fluorescents 2 inches over the tops. Using a nutrient schedule of
15ml of Iguana grow
30ml of voodoo juice
15ml of organic B
½ tsp of piranha
1tsp of tarantula


After 2 weeks repotted into 3 gal containers with a mixture of (1 part ocean forest, and 1 part perlite, on the bottom of the pot) and 1 part promix.
3 scoops of promix on top.
30ml of iguana grow
5ml of super tea grow
7.5ml of sweet leaf
30ml of voodoo juice


At onset of flowering I did.
15ml of Iguana bloom
5ml of super tea bloom
7.5ml of sweet leaf
30ml of voodoo juice


After a couple weeks I did alternate watering of
A: 15ml of iguana bloom
7.5ml of super tea bloom
15ml of organic B
15ml of sweet leaf

B: 15ml of iguana bloom
7.5ml of super tea bloom
20ml of big bud

Each week I sprayed them with Emerald Shaman for the 1st 3 weeks of flowing


They are currently in their 4th week of flowing and both sides are looking great, the only thing that I’ve been noticing that I’m not likening is there is a moldy film on the top of the soil of the Advanced side; I think that’s why they tell you to wait until they are bone dry before the next watering. I’ve been scraping the moldiness off (only like 1\4 of an inch) and adding promix on top, other than that the advanced side does look a little prettier, more triochromes. The Botanicare side has such a wonderful smell to it, does look very pretty as well. So far its prolly gonna end up in a blind taste test  and yield wise.
Pictures will come Tonight.
 
Last edited:
G

Guest

this is written up very well man :D rough draft material for me next season if you dont mind @!
 

DrLongbottom

Well-known member
Veteran
Excellent topic for a thread.....this is a comparison that I am sure many members will be eyeballing. Finally someone with a side by side full spectrum run. Peace DLB :joint:
 

WAMEN

Joint Date: Today.
Veteran
right on man :yes: hell of a nice thread i would say! im sure a lot of us will be followin it with interest.. good job.
 

Moppel

Grower for Life
Veteran
Looks great man. i will follow this for sure, always wanted to see a grow test with adv nutr.

good luck.
 

TokenBlackGuy

Active member
Not be a downer but this experiment is already kinda flawed in a little way.. Since you have used Bonanicare already and have been succesful then your results will most likely be better than AN because you have the routine down..
But i still do want to see the results... I have been slowly switching from FF to AN Organic Line..
 

T.doT.Toker

Leave this place better then when i arrived
Veteran
Good idea man. THis is going to be an interesting thread =) Take it easy bro.
 

clowntown

Active member
Veteran
:lurk:

Just to be clear though, I don't think their organic line is considered the "2+" program that they claim will produce better than their competitors; but instead, the organic line is something created to get the organic share of the market.
 

mtnjohn

Active member
Veteran
clowntown said:
:lurk:

Just to be clear though, I don't think their organic line is considered the "2+" program that they claim will produce better than their competitors; but instead, the organic line is something created to get the organic share of the market.
yes , that is true........they did however say that it (the organic line)
came very close to the 2+ program yeild wise and beat their competitors hands down


i'm curious to see what happens
good thread
mj
 

beancounter

Active member
Veteran
Interesting thread.. I'm doing something similar, but based on much more simpler recipes, and chem vs organic..

Using DWC (for the 1st time) and Bubba Kush clones.

I will be using AN 3 part (no additives) on one clone in flower, and PBP Bloom + calmag on the other clone..

This is my 1st time doing dwc and my 1st time doing organic (or mostly organic), so i look forward to the results..

the comparison will be based mostly on the taste, with all other things considered but not focused on..

Here's the thread.. maybe i put it in the wrong forum.. sorry for the slight hijack, but i thought some people may be interested in my results and progress..

http://www.icmag.com/ic/showthread.php?t=48168
 

jcsmooth

Member
Ants in ma pants. Ants in ma pants.
This is a start to a good thread, and thanks for sharing it with us.
Hopefully we can all give out advice and be as helpful as possible.

On that note, do you have a ppm/ec meter? Just wondering if your "levels" are roughly the same between your independent variables (AN or Botanicare).
Just thought I'd throw out a scientific method term for good measure

Can't wait to hear more,
JC
 

MMZRetro85

Active member
TokenBlackGuy said:
Not be a downer but this experiment is already kinda flawed in a little way.. Since you have used Bonanicare already and have been succesful then your results will most likely be better than AN because you have the routine down..
But i still do want to see the results... I have been slowly switching from FF to AN Organic Line..

I have actually have done AN before many times, 2 part A + B, and dabbled with a couple things from their organic line (iguana, voodoo) so i am firmilar to the point where i know you can actually really fuck your garden up mis-using Advanced. and yes i have had very good results with Botanicare, wasnt the BEST results that i'v gotten from using bcuzz bloom, age old, oxy-cal, and some other things that are ALMOST on an old-school level, to me atleast.
just to let ya know
peace````

 
Top