What's new
  • As of today ICMag has his own Discord server. In this Discord server you can chat, talk with eachother, listen to music, share stories and pictures...and much more. Join now and let's grow together! Join ICMag Discord here! More details in this thread here: here.

Bad Start....Not Getting Better :(

H

Hal

SOIL:

How long has this problem been going on? Since germination...about 30 days

What STRAIN are you growing? JLP's SDOG, and Sweet tooth x BOG's Lifesaver

What was the establishing technique? (seed or clone?) Seed

What is the age of your plants? About 33-34 days old.

How long have they been in the soil mixture they are in now? Same, 33-34 days
.

How Tall are the plants? Shortest is about 4", the tallest is about 8"

What PHASE (seedling, vegetative or flower) are the plants in? 12/12 for 18 days.

What Technique are you using? (SOG, SCROG etc) SOG

What size pots are you using? (Include how many subjects to pot) Pop bottles 7" t x 3" w

What substrate/medium are you using? What brand of soil mixture are you using?(percentage of perlite, vermiculite...etc?) FFOF (3/4) and perlite (1/4)

What Nutrient's are you using? molasses (once), EWC tea (once), PB Pro for soil (twice)

How much of each nutrient are you using with how much water? *Knowing the brand is very helpful* PB Pro...10 ml per gallon (first time), diluted by half second time.

How often are you feeding? See above.

If flowering, when did you switch over to using Bloom nutrients? first was 8 days ago

What is the TDS/EC/PPM of your nutrients used? Unkown, I don't have a meter.

What is the pH of the "RUN-OFF"? Not sure, I have been adjusting my tap water to 6.5

What method of pH test was administered? Using Strips? pH pen? Drops

How often are you watering? Only pre-watering.

When was your last feeding and how often are you feeding? Last feeding was 4 days ago.

What size bulb are you using? 153 watts of CFL's, 5 x 23 watt (warm), 2 x 18 watt (day)

What is the distance to the canopy? About 2-3 inches.

What is your RH Factor? (Relative Humidity) Between 20% and 35%.

What is the canopy temperature? Lights on between 83F & 89F, lights off about 70F.

What is the Day/Night Temp? (Include fluctuation range) See above.

What is the current Air Flow? (cfm etc.) 97 CFM pulling thru scrubber, 8x8 passive intake
This is in a micro cab, chamber size is 29" wide x 29" high x 11" deep

Tell us about your ventilation, intake exhaust and when its running and not running ?
Is the fan blowing directly at plants? No.

Is the grow substrate constantly wet or moist? Maybe....

Is your water HARD or SOFT? Tap water is about 7.5 to 8 (I don't have an accurate meter)

What water are you using? Tap, ph'ed to approx 6.5

Are you using water from a water softener? No

Has plant been recently pruned, cloned or pinched? No

Have any pest chemicals been used? If so what and when? No

Are plant's infected with pest's? No



Hello Helpful Medics :)

My apologies for this discombobulated grow I have going on. I havent' grown a garden in about a year and a half, I'm out of practice, and on top of that I made one significant fuck up in the beginning which might be where my problems lie.


About 18 months ago, I started a little garden. Not sure why, but all my seedlings died, previous to this I had what seemed a green thumb. In preparation for that garden I had prepared a tub with some fresh FFOF soil and perlite (I think it was 75% FFOF, 25% perlite, but it was a long time ago). Anyway, my seedlings all died, summer-time heat was knockin on the door, and I decided to postpone growing for a few months. That turned into about 18 months for a variety of reasons.

Back to the present....I'm ready to get going with a new garden. I decide to use the soil that I had put into the tub way back then, even though it had dried to dust. Stupid me, I thought I could just water it like fresh soil....stupid me.

I germed my seedlings, got 7 of JLP's SDOG beans to sprout, and got 4 Sweet tooth 1.1 X BOG's Lifesaver to show tail. I then placed these in little 3 oz (?) plastic cups with that same FFOF shitty soil in them watered and waited. All the beans burst forth toward the light.

I think one mistake I made was when preparing the little cups, I only put one drain hole in their bottoms, and I think the soil at the bottom remained kind of wet. The seedlings didn't seem to be growing at the same rate I had seen previous seedlings grow at. After they were in those little cups for about 10 days I decided to transplant into the pop bottles, thinking the roots were too soaked.

Anyways...I transplanted into the pop bottles. These were 1 liter bottles cut down to 7" high and they are 3" wide. There is about 1" of hydroton at the very bottom, and about 5.5" of that shitty soil mix. I watered these with tap water ph adjusted to approx 6.5, and mixed a molasses tea (1 tablespoon per gallon) and watered till there was runoff. At this time I noticed that a whole bunch of that shitty soil was not absorbing the water/tea.

Growth was still slow. There was yellowing happening to the first set of real leaves, at this point started thinking maybe my dirt was shitty. I decided to make a tea of EWC and water with that next time to see if I might bring some life back to this shitty soil.

I put these plants into 12/12 cycle when they were about 2 weeks old (I was originally planning on getting them into 12/12 from seed, but I read something saying you shouldn't put your plants into flower if they aren't healthy). At this point, since they had already been developing a root system for 2 weeks, I thought they might take off in their growth, and soon start their flower stretch period.

They continued to look generally unhealthy. I am generally a smart waterer, going by how heavy the pot feels. I was wondering if I was letting them dry out enough, I thought so, but they were looking droopy, which is a sign of over watering. BUT....I knew the soil was pretty bad, so I wasn't sure if that was playing a part.

I watered the next time with PB Pro for soil (1.5 - 4 - 5), 10 ml per gallon. At this point I had decided to water with the soak method, to make sure the entire body of soil was inundated with liquid. The soil seemed to be repelling the water previously, maybe leaving dry spots in the middle.

3 days later, the pots felt pretty light (they are so so small, its not as easy telling the difference between fully watered and dry). I decided to water the 2 lightest of the plants. I soaked these with that same PB Pro solution, but diluted to half the strength by adding more water (I thought I may have gone to strong the first time). These plants seemed to respond very favorably. I thought that might be a sign they were needing nutes, so the next day I soaked the remaining plants in that solution. They all seemed to perk up. Thought I may have solved the problem.

For some reason, I'm not sure why, I decided to water them about a day and a half later. I think what happened was they initially perked up, then started getting droopy again, so I thought they might need some more nutes. But I remember them still being pretty heavy, so I think they were still pretty wet. As I considered what I had done, I started thinking that I likely over watered.

So...I haven't watered them since, about 4 days ago. Remember, there isn't much soil in these containers, only about 5.5" high x 3" wide. So, it would seem unlikely they could go much longer, there appeared to be a significant root system to suck up the water. But they are still looking droopy, some worse than others.

On top of the droopiness, there definitely seems to be a nute shortage going on, my guess would be N, but not sure if I'm correct. There seems to be an unfortunately large number of variables that could be coming into play here (shitty soil, shitty dry soil, small containers, slow start because of ?, you name the others). On top of that, I'm growing in a new cab for the first time, and battling temp levels that are on the border of being unacceptable.

Regarding the small size of the container I'm growing in....these are actually a little bigger than others I have seen. DrBudGreenjeans has a few threads going, and gets great results in smaller bottles, and others have copied him and gotten good results. I understand it isn't the ideal root environment for the girls, but I don't think it is toxic.

I am starting to get the feeling that these plants are never going to get healthy, and put all this work into a truly miniscule harvest. I'm starting to get the idea I should just chuck this grow and start over with good, fresh soil. But, these are the nicest genetics I have ever had the opportunity to grow, and I really don't want to toss them.

Can anyone help me?

Sorry for the longlonglong post...I always try to provide as much info as possible, sometimes to the extreme.:1help:










 
H

Hal

OK..

I can't find out why the hell I'm having this upload problem. I was having problems with the search function earlier in the evening...whatever term I searched for, whatever thread, it would take me to a results page that was totally blank. The image size limit is supposed to be 1 mb, and my photos were originally under that (about 750k), didn't work, so I went back to photoshop and reduced them further, to about 200 k, and I'm still being told my file sizes are to big.

I ate a big brownie about one hour ago....and I don't think I can think clearly enough from this point on to make progress with this tonight, I've searched for answer for 15 minutes and cannot find one.

This will have to wate tilll tomroroo2ww..
 
H

Hal

OK...got some pictures up. Can't frikkin believe how small the file size has to be for me to upload...150K...sheesh.

Hope the photos are helpful.
 

theHIGHlander

european ganja growers
Veteran
hi bro ..you want to do something with the bottles, eg tape black paper/bags around them , roots HATE light.
some new soil and a transplant into black/ non see through pots should see them ok. you seem to have abit off cal/mag issue going down aswell which is proberly down to the crap soil..

keep it green
highlander
 

Sleepy

Active member
Veteran
this may be your issue:

this may be your issue:

Is your water HARD or SOFT? Tap water is about 7.5 to 8 (I don't have an accurate meter)

What water are you using? Tap, ph'ed to approx 6.5

you need to get a handle on your pH, Hal...

you need to know where the pH is before you correct it...i think you will continue to compound the problems until you fix the lockout.

either fix/calibrate you meter or get a new one.

then flush with pH 6.0-6.5 until the runoff matches the new liquid.

recovery is about a week away.

don't give up yet, Hal...you can save them for sure!!

you'll go from this:



to this:

 
I had the exact same problem, I think it was a combination of overwater and UNDER-FEEDING -- they wanted Nitrogen, and I never gave them enough.
 

D0MiN0

Member
You might solve overwatering problems by ading some H2o2 to the water... I use 3-4ml per liter... This way I add a lot of water but peroxide keeps the roots from drowning.
Hope that helps...
 
H

Hal

Hey All...

Thanks for the diagnosis'....This grow, as mentioned in the first post, started with a mistake, and that is NOT the way to do a grow. I hope this can serve as a warning to any newbs that might potentially make a similar dumb move. If you start off with weak soil, how can you really know what other variables could be playing a part in the problem...it might all boil down to the initial soil problem. Ah well, live and learn :)

Sleepy! Dude! Thanks for your keen eye...I agree with ya about the importance of the PH, if you have a fucked up PH its as bad as starting with shitty soil. I think my description above may have suggested that my PH is potentially more out of whack than it is. Although I don't have a PH meter, I do use those drops, and I am pretty confident that I am adjusting my tap water to almost exactly 6.5. I have used these same drops for my previous grows and never found problems before.

The tap water's original PH is about 7.5 or so, I can't remember what reading I got. When I first noticed there seemed to be a problem with the plants I did test the PH of the run-off from the bottom of the bottle, and it was unchanged by going through the soil, it was still 6.5. So, I am inclined to rule the PH as the source of problems, at least for the moment.

Hey Highlander....

I'm not sure if the roots being exposed to light is causing any problems here. I agree with you that it is not the ideal environment for the roots, nor is the small growing space for them. I did a bit of research on light hitting the roots, and the info I encountered seemed to suggest that it is best to have the light blocked, having light hitting the roots/soil probably would, at worst, facilitate the growth of some algae, which doesn't hurt anything. I remain open to more info on this though, if ya can point me in the direction of a thread that addresses this.

One thing that won't be happening...is a transplant into new soil. I have already culled a few males after putting the plants into 12/12, and when removing the soil from those bottles, I encountered a fairly thick root system, and found removing the soil a bit difficult due to the ridges on the bottle....the soil and roots had worked their way into the ridges. So, removing the plant to put into new soil would almost certainly damage the plant.

The calcium/magnesium deficiency might be right on...they do seem like they are needing something. I'll have to go to Stitches thread and examine what these deficiencies look like.

Speaking of that....Where is Stitch? Is there a Dr. in the house?!

Hey El Gato...

Thanks dude. I think you might be right. I'm pretty sure that I have overwatered these girs, as much as I have been trying to avoid that. Really pisses me off, that I am aware of the overwatering problem, paying attention to avoid doing that, and still making the error. DOH! DOH! DOHDOHDOH!!! I guess figuring out the nutrients that the girls are needing is the next step. I'm guessing they need some nitrogen, but I am not sure how hard I should hit them with some N due to there being in flower now (albeit the very early stages). I'm also not sure what the best way to deliver N to them would be...was thinking about diluting some of my urine, sounds gross but supposedly is just fine.

HinduKushMaster...

Another vote for hiding the roots from the light....starting to see a pattern here :)

Midwestganga...

Sounds like your advice/observations is about the same as El Gato's. If you had a similar situation, that counts for a lot. Do you have any suggestions on the nutrients the plants might be hankering for..?

Domino...

Interesting. So, adding the peroxide throws an extra molecule of oxygen into the solution, and provides some extra O2 to the roots? Are you sure about the 3-4 ml per liter as being a safe amount? Sounds like a possible solution, but I would like to hear some body else confirm the safety of that direction.

OH YEAH...something I forgot to mention. I haven't been oxygenating my water before I put the bottles in for a soak. How important is that? I don't have one of those bubblers at the moment, and won't be able to buy one (or anything, for that matter) soon due to the fucking fucked economy...I'm getting bitch slapped by the job market now. But, if it is important to get air into the water, I'm sure I could just agitate the hell out of it before putting the plants in for their drink.

Thanks to all you guys for your help.
 
u dont need oxygenated water man.. your runoff was 6.5 you say?? thats within range if your in soil, unless im mistaken.
i
f i were u id transplant in fresh soil and put more drainage holes.. they look underfed and overwatered to me. oh i see your not transplanting.. maybe try to cut more holes in bottom of container so u get better drainage. i like usin a box razor for that personally.

your plants look pretty big being in a 1 liter bottle.. if u flower u will have rootbound issues i bet.

id probably try to work some dolomite in there to help buffer the acidity too

good luck
 

Weedhound

Grower
ICMag Donor
Yep, poor supplies from start to finish. Shiny clear bottles for the roots to show, poor soil quality (as mentioned by the grower himself) and not sure about the ph because going off drops. If you didn't have them under light I could say you skipped EVERYTHING the plant needs (oops...except water....which is possiby assisting your deficiency issues)

You insist you aren't going to make the changes you should make (I'm not transplanting) but the way those plants look you may want to reconsider. You see, while keeping roots dark and giving them plenty of growing room etc might not seem feasable to you......I have think STRONGLY that the plants feel differently and will continue to let you know that they are not happy by their poor look and grow rate.

I would say you need to transplant up, into better soil and larger (covered) containers with better drainage. In other words, change just about everything. sorry.


good luck.
 
H

Hal

Weedhound...

Maybe you missed it, but, due to the architecture of the bottles I'm growing in (with ridges in the plastic), removing the soil will be just about impossible without damaging the plant severely. This is why I'm not considering a transplant.

Regarding the PH drops, I understand that isn't the absolute best method of guageing the PH, but I have seen many respected growers here on IC state that using these drops gets you close enough to a correct reading, so it is a valid method of PH control.

I've also seen a number of folks growing with clear plastic with excellent results. Of course, preventing the light from hitting the roots will be what they find in their natural environment, and therefore would be more preferable than the alternative. But, again, many have used clear plastic bottles, and grown excellent cannabis.

My drainage is fine, don't know why you think it isn't. You should see all the holes in the bottoms of the bottles.

I realize this isn't a "standard" growing method...I'm growing in a micro-environment, as I stated in the original post, and this frequently requires things be done in a different way, almost always using components that have a reduced size to fit the micro cabinet. If I had more area to be growing, I wouldn't be doing it this way. BUT I DON'T, so I'm doing the best that I can.

Your post is on the harsh side, seeming more critical than helpful in nature.

Thanks for chipping in anyways.
 
Hal, funny you say you're using drops too. I just switched to a PH Pen a while ago and it is making the difference, the entire time I was using drops I was experiencing your problems to a T. Now, I think my PH was high at the time, which was causing nitrogen lockout, as well as cal-mag and K, so then I started watering more thinking it was too dry, overall it was a clusterfuck, and they looked 100% like your plants. If I would have done things differently I would have had a PH Pen to begin with and I guarantee I would have never ran into problems. As far as administering N to your plants in early flower, it's fine. Just give them a half strength or normal strength of grow or whatever you use for veg, it should be no problem this early in flower.

Glad I came across this because I couldnt find anyone with pics that looked just like mine, you can look at my gallery and see how they progressed later on, they were N locked out for weeks IMO. doing good now though :rasta:
 

theHIGHlander

european ganja growers
Veteran
Hal what about takeing a stanly knife and cutting the bottle in 2 ????...eg cut down a few inches on ether side ,then stick some tape to hold to top so the soil dont fall out, then cut down to the bottom , take the tape off and split the bottle (put the plant/ bottle on there side .on a table /ground)= job done, ready for transplant,,,,,throw the bottles and get drinking more juice for some new bottles/pots :yes::2cents:

hope it all comes good bro,,,

keep it green
highlander
 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top