What's new
  • ICMag with help from Landrace Warden and The Vault is running a NEW contest in November! You can check it here. Prizes are seeds & forum premium access. Come join in!

Afghanistan

Yarkand

Active member
Something i just found on the web.

Enjoy & Peace



My First Time Overland
To & Through Afghanistan
By Tom Cole
Lemar-Aftaab
July - December 2000


[click on images to view larger photos]


TRAVELLING overland to Asia was the thing to do in the late 1960s and early 1970s, something which appealed to me after I had met two friends of my older brother who had returned to Berkeley from travels to Kathmandu and Cambodia.

But I did not have the nerve to take a break from college with the Vietnam war raging and every available kid who was either too stupid or too poor being picked out and chosen to serve. The impartial lottery system which did away with student deferments freed me, and in the fall of 1970, I was off to seek what would prove to be my life's fortune on the steppes of Central Asia.

I landed in London on my 19th birthday, not a bad present to myself, and briefly meandered through Europe en route to Istanbul, an ancient city standing at the crossroads of the East and West. At that time, Istanbul was a fairly inhospitable place, the populace resentful of the flock of travellers who passed through their narrow streets and alleys where an inordinate number of junkies and other abusers of the culture had lurked for years.

I was happy to leave Turkey, but Iran was not much different. Persian men went out their way to throw and elbow or shoulder at me and my other companions as we traversed the streets of then fashionable Tehran; our longish hair and loose Western ways were anathema in that bastion of Shiite Islam, caviar, wine and all the other accourtrements of an oil fueled economy. The Shah was not so bad for Iran, they prospered as neverbefore and maybe never again. In any case, the locals were not popualr with young Western travellers and undoubtedly, we were not their favorites either.

Having survived the absolutely awful dirt and stone track which ran most of the way from Tehran to Mashad, the final push to the Persian border town was easy. I remember we had no place to stay. There were no hotels per se in this small border outpost, so we stayed in a caraveserai where the principal patrons were itinerant Afghan traders and businessmen.

This was my first introduction to Afghan culture. We threw our sleeping bags down on the floor in one corner and proceeded to get comfortable for the night. The lights went out, but that was homegrown pleasures of their country. Numerous cigarettes were lit and the wafting fragrance of hashish reached us. A man leaned over, offering me his cigarette as well as assurances that the doors were locked and we were free and safe to partake in their pleasure. At this time, as well as currently, smuggling hashish into Iran is a huge offense, and I just assumed smoking it carried the same penalties. I quickly went to sleep, with anxious expectations of reaching Afghanistan the next day.

By the time we arose the next morning and finally hit the road, after some repairs on the bus which was transporting us and that driven by an Afghan, it was afternoon, and we could not expect to reach the frontier borderpost before dark. Sure enough, we finally rolled into Islam Qala after dark, had our passports stamped with an entry and were ceremoniously ushered into the customs hall. There, a young officer invited us to enjoy a water pipe, right there just behind the customs hall. A customs man giving us a plaque of hashish and a water pipe! Truly surreal.

But then we smoked and everything changed. The sky, brilliantly clear and studded with millions of stars, began to undulate, the desert surrounding us became a magical land, reeking with history and the spirits of the past flitting by in the flashing darkness.

And Afghanistan had a story of which I was virtually unaware at that tender age. I had no idea who the Baluch were, or Turkomans, Uzbeks or Tajiks. Or anything about this country. I did know Genghis Khan had rolled through here, laying waste to everyone and everything, but the cultural context in which all of this history had occured was truly beyond my understanding at that early time.

Thirty years later, I can say I have learned a few things over the course of my life and gained some experience. Guess this sort of life experience was what my own father had referred to much earlier in my life, but his experience seemed much more important than my own. He had volunteered to fight the fascists in Spain in the 1930s, a member of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade. And I was in a medieval, landlocked country in Central Asia, smoking hashish with government customs agents. Very different, indeed.

Herat was a beautiful city, the tinkling of bells from the horse carts filling the air, the sound of the hooves on the pavement of the main street disappearing into the night as I settled in at the hotel on that first night. It all seemed so magical, so different. And it was. And still is, I am told by recent travellers to that city. In spite of 20 years of war, Herat is still a nice place, especially when most of the cars migrated to Kabul during the war period, and it was left to the poorer inhabitants and the mujahideen.

The mosque there is wondrous, my first experience with real Islamic architecture that I could appreciate. (The Byzantine structures of Istanbul were too overwhelming for my formative mind, and Shiite Iran just was not very welcoming, hardly affording the time to digest and enjoy what one was seeing.) I could wander the gardens of the mosque in Herat, sit and enjoy the movie before my eyes, locales taken right out of an old travelogue.

All the people were dressed in native attire. Western attitude (nor the inevitable anti-Western bias) had not encroached upon this native scene, and all seemed as it had been for the last five hundred years or so. Scribes offered their services, fortune tellers teased passers by with a glimpse of the future, little boys played with sticks and stones. Completely medieval.

Wandering the back alleys of the city provided endlessly fascinating. The fabeled minarets of Herat were startling in the midst of this mud city. No one bothered me as I aimlessly wandered, stumbling through time and space in search of nothing in particular but a changing landscape before my thirsty eyes. Hungering for something different, I found more than I could possibly fathom. I saw a man drinking from a small stream while another man upstream urinated into the same water. I was astounded. No wonder disease was rampant in such countries, and I found myself afraid to even brush my teeth with the tap water much less drink it. I was amazed. And slightly horrified as well.

Kandahar was an entirely different scene. The Kandaharis were famous for their huge waterpipes and the ludicrous amounts of hashish with which they filled them. I stayed at a hotel in the main square of Kandahar which, I found out later, was run by a drug smuggler, a supplier of contraband for organized business (not crime, as the patrons were only criminals if they were caught. Otherwise, they just seemed like normal guys who like to smoke hashish. And sell it, apparently). It was Ramazan, a holiday to which I was totally oblivious, but the hotel keeper and stafff were busy partying on the eve of the first night of the holy month. I imagined this was how it was done all the time and really had no clue as to the significance of anything.

Kabul, on the other hand, was like an oasis in a sense. In Shar-e Nau (the new city), women sported French fashion, high heels, attractive hosiery, finely tailored dresses, and the like. Not every woman dressed like this, but after Herat and Kandahar, Kabul seemed to be a much more cosmopolitan city. But that was only a superficial observation.

For the most part, the city was a bit staid to my unfamiliar eye and mind, with little of the blatant charm of Herat nor the cowboy criminal aspects of Kandahar. This was the capital, the seat of power from where King Zahir Shah presided over his kingdom of disparate tribes and geography. His picture hung in every chai khanna, every restaurant and shop.

I believe he was loved at the time, as the rule of law did not seem to be enforced through a show of arms or strength. Army recruits were treated well, given free cups of tea as a mean of showing support for these dirt poor souls who found themselves in the bedraggled dress of the Afghan Army. Only upon the ascent of the first Communist power did the army uniforms become significantly upgraded.

I did not feel comfortable that first time in Afghanistan, finding it a bit disconcerting to be caught in a medieval environment, surrounded by people with whom I could not communicate and a culture of which I had no understanding.

I flew to Pakistan after only a few days in Kabul, anxious to flee that medieval and primitive land, finding the imprint of British colonialism firmly intact which provided a bit of solace for me, travelling alone in the heart of Asia. The sub-continent was a place of fantasy and the fantastic. Hindustan proved to be fascinating, replete with a temperate climate, incredible Hindu holy men and rituals, exotic spice and fantastic festivals. I did not return to Afghanistan for another two years when I finally fell in love with the arid steppe land, a relationship which changed my life forever.

I remember a lighting from an Indian train in Benares in the summer of 1973, the Hindu haven of death on the holy river Ganga, and perusing the screaming headlines of the Indian Express: "King Zahir Shah Overthrown in Bloodless Coup!"

I had no idea that this would mark the beginning of the end for a land to which I hand since become inexorably drawn. My attraction had not been so indefinite to be confined to just the land; I had even experienced a memorable infatuation with a pretty and charming Afghan college student, the daughter of a prominent UN employee whom I had met in a public call office in New Delhi subsequent to the Soviet invasion. But that is another story for another time.

Over the year, I have become a modest collector of art from the steppes and am considered an 'expert' by some, though my time of learning and quest for further knowledge is never ending. My fascination with the material culture of the Turkoman, Uzbeks and Baluch has been a satisfying experience, one from which I have derived much pleasure as well as a living, though not without very accomodating (sorry, this is a bit unclear) to those who find themselves dwelling upon and collecting artifacts from the past, surrounding themselves with antique textiles and rugs.

My trip to Mazar-i-Sharif in March 1997 was a wondrous, invigorating experience as I was able to gain perspective upon both my own past as well as that of Afghanistan itself. I can recall the quality of life there prior to the horrors of the last 10 years, the fresh clear air, the overflowing platters of fragrant fruits, the hearty palau and succulent lamb, snow capped peaks and bountiful orchards and vineyards, moonlit summer evenings relaxing outside in walled gardens listening to the sonorous rhythms of classical robab music on a small tape recorder.

At that time, we thought we were on top of the world in all respects and in a sense, we were. My memories are distinct and vivid. There was no place like Afghanistan at that time and perhaps, sadly, there never will be again.


Other Work by Tom Cole:

* The Texture of Time
(October-December 1998)
* Diamond in the Rough
(April-September 1999)


Related Links:

* Afghanistan Adventure
By Dennis B. Armstrong
(January-March 2000)
* Lessons in Growing up in Afghanistan
By Caryn Giles Lawson
(April-June 2000)
* Tremors on the Volcano: Afghanistan in Early 1979
By Terence Odlin
(January-March 1999)
* Reminiscences of Afghanistan
By Chuck Burress
(July-September 1997)
* Adventures of the Zelzelah Man in Farkhaar
By Steven Roecker
(April-June 1998)
* The First Slap of War: An Uncompleted Tour of My Homeland
By Daud Saba
(October-December 1999)
* Long Road Back to Afghanistan
By Farid Shah Karimi
(October-December 1997)
* Summer of 96 in Kabul
By Sayed Ehsan
(October-December 1997)

:wave:
 

DocLeaf

procreationist
ICMag Donor
Veteran
'An Unexpected Light - Travels in Afghanistan' by Jason Elliot

'An Unexpected Light - Travels in Afghanistan' by Jason Elliot

For anyone interested in Afghanistan, 'An Unexpected Light - Travels in Afghanistan' by Jason Elliot provides a unique insight into the lands and its peoples during both Soviet and early Telebe occupation.

The book tells of the adventures of a young English student (a scholar of Arabic) during his gap year as he travels about Afghanistan on his own. So as to be allowed the freedom of the mountains he is soon recruited into the Mujaheddin (those who struggle). Quickly he learns of the people, the culture, and the non-forgiving landscape, in a time when Afghan orchards still bloomed.

Review: http://www.bookreporter.com/reviews/0312288468.asp

"At the base of the slope, along a path shaded by high walls of wild cannabis, there was an orchard of apricot, apple and walnut trees. I had the habit of wandering there and writing my diary by the stream". (p105)

"Here the rock and water of which the junction was configured had channelled the flow of the fates of civilizations. I wondered what tales a pebble from one of the valley's cracked bastions might tell of all the languages uttered in its shadow."


The book is arguably one of the greatest works of non-fiction of the last century, since Jason King is a master of launguage. The best seller also won the 'Travel Book Award'. It was written well before 911 and the issues raises by the author then,,, are still poignant today.

Anyone interested in Afghanistan should read this!
 
Last edited:
C

Chamba

The book is arguably one of the greatest works of non-fiction of the last century, since Jason King is a master of launguage. The best seller also won the 'Travel Book Award'. It was written well before 911 and the issues raises by the author then,,, are still poignant today.

so true ...'An Unexpected Light - Travels in Afghanistan' by Jason Elliot ..is a wonderful read..and one of the best books I've read lately (and I read about 50 books per year) ..I've recommended it to many fellow readers
 
G

Guest

Yes, thanks Doc, will be getting that one in very shortly!

Peace, hhf
 

ngakpa

Active member
Veteran
Documentary - Afghanistan 1979 - 1989
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtb1kkW0G9A
Mujahadeen fight off Soviet invasion

Afghanistan - 2006
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-848138069432834535&q=Afghanistan

longer documentary - 66 minute made by Soviet soldier 1988 (not in English obviously)
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-5931942340790284291&q=Afghanistan+Soviet

Western Invasion of Afghanistan - Massacres and War Crimes?
http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay...5&q=Afghanistan
Jamie Doran - journalist tortured and beaten for making this documentary?
 
Last edited:

Rastatrue

Active member
Where a man could be King

Where a man could be King

Hey now, This looks like a nice read. Too bad those days are long since past.
I fear the day US/Nato troops come home, bringng the junk with them.
I recall wandering around Western Europe in 73 listening intently about Nepal & Afghanistan. Which route to travel? Stories of Iraqi/Iranian security police.
Seeing this account today made me remember a guy telling me how he got to Kabul. Visiting a local Hash spot, he saw a man in deep trance, levitate. Right, floating in the air! I did'nt believe him then either. Still as we shared a chillum. A great way to smoke/with the silk damp cloth to cool the smoke. I tried to change his story. "No way, he was floating in the air?" Still,today looking back, I believe him now. Back then it seemed like anything was possible. Maybe the smoke was that good that with practice you too could float. You know like a magic carpet type of ride. Thanks again for sharing this tale. :joint:
 

ngakpa

Active member
Veteran
good article on Afghanistan - gives flavour of real Pashtun culture too

good article on Afghanistan - gives flavour of real Pashtun culture too

http://www.nthposition.com/mysummervacationin.php

My summer vacation in Afghanistan
by Peter Lamborn Wilson, 2003

First time in Afghanistan, late winter 1968/9, making the Overland Trail fast as possible through howling cold of Central Asian steppes. Minibus from Mashhad to Herat, arriving at the border crossing: dark, dusty, cold and bleak. (Later, I was to discover that somehow Afghan border crossings were always dark dusty cold bleak, even on nice summer days.) Busload of hippies pulls up at the checkpoint. Suddenly a huge Afghan officer with bristling moustaches and fierce scowl thrusts himself into the bus: "Any you got hashish?" he screamed.

Chorus of "No," "No," "Not me," Not me, Sir" - squeaky and scared. What the hell?

"Sssooo..." hissed the officer, reaching menacingly into his jacket... "You like to buy?" He whipped out a chunk of hash the size of a loaf of Wonder Bread. "Very good, grade-A Afghani."

... follow link for complete article... Balkh/Mazar hashisih:

Later that winter I suffered on through Bactria itself, to Mazar-i-Sharif, over mountain passes in a blizzard in an unheated bus. Sometimes in the middle of the night and howling snowstorms the bus stopped - to let a camel cross the highway. Shivering and amazed, I counted about 25 big Bactrians, humps frosted with snow, and heard for the first time the clanking of caravan bells, a sound used as a cliché in Persian poetry to signify "departure", with all its sadness and anticipation. The caravaneers muffled in padded sheepskins and turbans of snow yanked the undulating giants by ropes through their noses, exhorting and cursing as the beasts honked and groaned. Then they disappeared into the storm heading north for the Soviet border.

* * *

Later, I managed to get to Balkh, the ancient capital of Bactria. The old city walls with watchtowers are still crumbling under the blows they received 700 years ago from the Mongols. We drove through a vast gate into a city that wasn't there, then kept on driving. On the inside of the wall was the same desert as on the outside. I think it was 16kms, all inside the wall, before we reached the centre and the shattered remains of Balkh: a ruined mausoleum (the dome collapsed) still flowery with patches of Timurid tile; the tomb of a Sufi shaykh in the line of Ibn 'Arabi. In a circle around the tomb, a dozen or so teahouses were huddled together, nothing else, not even trees - just central Asian desert and patches of snow. The great "Mother of Cities", birthplace of Jalaloddin Rumi, already a metropolis when Alexander conquered it, now nothing but a flattened waste and the Ozymandian stump of a cenotaph.

There's an old Sufi legend about Genghis Khan (said to be part of The Secret History of the Mongols, but I could never find any translation): he's just 14 and hiding out alone in the desert from his enemies. He goes to sleep in a cave and dreams of the Bodhisattva Avalokiteshvara, who gives him a gold ring and tells him that his mission is to go forth and destroy civilisation, to remove the blight of cities from the world. When he wakes, the ring is still on his finger. As far as Balkh is concerned, Genghis Khan did his duty, or one of his descendants did it for him. I forget which.

Only one thing kept Balkh alive in 1971: hashish. The chai-khanehs were set up to host a charas bazaar, and the famous north Afghani green-gold enticed gourmet connoisseurs from all over the universe. I wasn't there to buy n bulk, however, just a few "candy canes" of the Number One, so I drank sweet tea with cardamom and sat around sampling the product with the extremely genial host.
 
Last edited:

ngakpa

Active member
Veteran
but why is production in Balkh down? ... see following post for research by Adam Pain

but why is production in Balkh down? ... see following post for research by Adam Pain

http://www.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,,2157193,00.html
UN horrified by surge in opium trade in Helmand


Despite 7,000 UK troops, Taliban-backed production up 48%

Declan Walsh
Tuesday August 28, 2007
The Guardian


Britain's drug policy in Afghanistan's Helmand province lay in tatters yesterday as the UN declared a "frightening" explosion in opium production across the country, led by Taliban-backed farmers in the volatile south. Opium production soared by 34% to 8,200 tonnes, accounting for 93% of world supply and most of the heroin sold in Britain and Europe, the UN Office on Drugs and Crime reported.
The record crop was fuelled by Helmand, where, despite the deployment of 7,000 British soldiers and millions of pounds in development spending, opium cultivation surged by 48%.


Article continues

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The sprawling and violent province is now the world's single largest source of illegal drugs - greater than coca from Colombia, cannabis from Morocco or heroin from Burma, countries with populations up to 20 times greater.
A despondent UNODC noted that no other country has produced illegal narcotics on such a scale since China in the 19th century. "The situation is dramatic and getting worse by the day," said its director general, Antonio Maria Costa.

The sole bright spot was a sharp fall in poppy cultivation in the north, where the number of drug-free provinces doubled from six to 13. Balkh province, which produced 7,200 hectares last year, eliminated poppy cultivation entirely. The disparity highlights a widening gap between relatively stable northern Afghanistan, where the Kabul government enjoys some authority, and the insurgency-racked south, where it has virtually none.

Favourable weather, Taliban insurgents and corrupt government officials all contributed to this year's record poppy haul, which has edged Afghanistan perilously close to becoming a full narco-state. The opium trade involves 3.3 million of Afghanistan's 23 million population, according to the UNODC, and accounts for more than half of its estimated $7.5bn (£3.7bn) gross domestic product.

Western countries, led by the US, have spent several billion pounds trying to eradicate the trade since 2001. But it has only grown stronger, and this year's dismal results are likely to revive a controversial debate on aerial crop spraying that pits America against the UK.

The US ambassador, William Wood, who was previously posted to Colombia, advocates dispatching squadrons of pesticide-filled crop duster planes to spray the poppy fields. Ground-based eradication destroyed 19,000 hectares this year, or one tenth of the total crop. But British and Afghan officials are trenchantly opposed to aerial spraying, arguing that it would only anger Afghan farmers and drive their families into the arms of the Taliban.

The Taliban have firmly entrenched themselves in the trade. Having vehemently opposed opium as "un-Islamic" in 2000, when the crop was virtually eliminated, the insurgents are now among its greatest champions. In Helmand, Taliban fighters protect poppy-growing farmers in exchange for a slice of their profits, and some commanders help to smuggle drugs. Their profits pay for arms, logistics and militia wages, the UN said.

Embarrassingly for the British, the Taliban have also linked poppy growing with military strategy. The town of Musa Qala, which the British military ceded to Taliban control last February, has become a major drugs hub. Opium is traded openly in the town bazaar and heroin processing labs have moved to the area.

The drug barons run little risk of being caught. No major smuggler has been arrested in Afghanistan since 2001. Yesterday Mr Costa urged President Hamid Karzai to submit a dozen major traffickers - whom he did not name - to the UN Security Council for inclusion on a Taliban sanctions list.

Frustrated western anti-narcotics specialists are also searching for fresh ideas that work. A senior British official said the UK will spend £10m on development projects in Helmand and contribute to a £13m "good performance" fund that rewards drug-free provinces.

Nato may also take a more aggressive role. Although western soldiers will not slash through fields of poppy - something British soldiers have always avoided - their commanders may start to target insurgents who double as drug smugglers. "There will be an overlap between counter-narcotics and counter-insurgency targets. We want people who are big in the insurgency and drugs to realise they don't enjoy impunity," said the British official.

But, he admitted, there was no silver bullet to kill the trade: "I expect it will be a long time before this problem is solved."

· The article above was amended on Thursday August 30 2007. We said in the story above that the Balkh province produced 7,200 tonnes of poppy last year. We meant 7,200 hectares. This has been changed.
 
Last edited:

ngakpa

Active member
Veteran
Afghanistan: When Counternarcotics Undermines Counterterrorism

Afghanistan: When Counternarcotics Undermines Counterterrorism

http://www.twq.com/05autumn/index.cfm?id=179


Afghanistan: When Counternarcotics Undermines Counterterrorism

Vanda Felbab-Brown is a Ph.D. candidate in political science at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and a fellow at Harvard University’s Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs.

Today’s counternarcotics chic contains the idea of a fundamental synergy among curbing the international drug trade, fighting the war on terrorism, and promoting democracy. In recent years, widespread attention to these links has introduced hip new terms such as narcoterrorism, narcoguerrilla, narcostate, and narcofundamentalism into the lexicon of U.S. officials, major international organizations, and the larger policy community. In Afghanistan, presumably consistent counterinsurgency, democratic stabilization, and counternarcotics measures have become the cornerstone of the international community’s policies. A huge explosion of opium poppy cultivation since the fall of the Taliban has led President Hamid Karzai, the United States, and the United Kingdom—the lead nation responsible for counternarcotics activity in Afghanistan under the UN Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA) framework—as well as major international organizations to declare that drugs now constitute the greatest threat to Afghanistan’s democratic consolidation and economic development. The prevailing strategy to prevent Afghanistan from becoming irretrievably addicted to its narcoeconomy has been to intensify counternarcotics efforts. Karzai has declared a war against poppies, describing the Afghan opium trade as a worse “cancer” than terrorism or the Soviet invasion of 1979. In March 2005, the Pentagon even expanded the mission of U.S. military forces in Afghanistan to include support of counternarcotics operations, including “transportation, planning assistance, intelligence, [and] targeting packages,” as well as in extremis support for Drug Enforcement Administration and Afghan officers who come under attack.

Yet, paradoxically, counternarcotics efforts frequently complicate counterterrorism and counterinsurgency objectives and can also undermine democratization in fragile situations. Counternarcotics measures frequently threaten the security environment by undermining efforts at political stabilization and democratic consolidation without addressing the underlying economic causes. They compromise intelligence gathering, alienate rural populations, and allow local renegade elites successfully to agitate against the central government. Among the three most common counternarcotics strategies—eradication, interdiction, and alternative development—eradication poses potentially disastrous risks for Afghanistan’s political stabilization and economic reconstruction while interdiction greatly complicates counterterrorism objectives. The obstacles to achieving successful alternative development are enormous. A fourth, softer strategy toward the drug dealers—amnesty—also entails serious negative repercussions.


Download the full article, available in Adobe Acrobat [.pdf] format.
 

ngakpa

Active member
Veteran
AREU - Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit www.areu.org.af

AREU - Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit www.areu.org.af

PRESS RELEASE FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
29 August 2006

ERADICATION WITHOUT VIABLE LEGAL ALTERNATIVES MAY UNDERMINE STATE BUILDING EFFORTS IN AFGHANISTAN

Eradicating opium poppy prior to establishing legal alternative income opportunities for farmers does not contribute to the long-term elimination of Afghanistan’s drug crop, and risks undermining the already strained relationship between communities and the state, argues a
new briefing paper from the Kabul-based Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit (AREU).

Preliminary figures reported by the media showed that the country’s opium cultivation will likely hit record levels this year, up by more than 40 percent from 2005, despite hundreds of millions of dollars in counternarcotics spending. Final figures will be released by the UN Office on Drugs and Crime in early September. Last year, the UN reported that Afghanistan produced
an estimated 4,500 tons of opium -- enough to make 450 tons of heroin --nearly 90 percent of world supply.

According to the AREU paper “Opium Poppy Eradication: How to raise risk when there is nothing to lose?”, this year’s bumper crop highlights the need for state building, development, and a rigorous implementation of Afghanistan’s multifaceted National Drug Control Strategy, not for increased eradication (meaning the physical destruction of crops, as opposed to the
elimination of the opium economy as a whole). Authors David Mansfield and Adam Pain contend that efforts to reduce the opium economy should focus on providing viable alternatives for those whose livelihoods depend on opium poppy cultivation, and avoid a more aggressive
stance on eradication.

Drawing on five years of fieldwork and on research conducted in 2006 in four different provinces (Balkh, Ghor, Kunduz and Nangarhar), Mansfield and Pain look at the relationship between eradication of opium poppy, changes in the perceived risk associated with its cultivation, and farmers’ decisions on whether or not to plant. They conclude that unless there
are other legal income opportunities available, the destruction of a crop may in fact lead to increased poppy cultivation in subsequent seasons as farmers seek to recover lost income. Only when they have real alternatives does the threat of eradication actually impact farmers’ decisions whether or not to cultivate opium poppy.

In Afghanistan’s current environment, characterized by worsening security -- especially in opium-producing areas -- and increasing disillusionment with the government, a focus on eradication rather than state building and alternative livelihoods may push farmers into the hands of the Taliban and other anti-government elements. Comparative evidence from Peru, Colombia and Thailand shows that pursuing aggressive eradication campaigns prior to the
establishment of security and accountable government often fuels popular resentment against the authorities, thereby undermining efforts to build a social contract between communities and the state.

“Opium Poppy Eradication: How to raise risk when there is nothing to lose?” is available for download at the AREU website, www.areu.org.af and in hard-copy at AREU’s office in Kabul.


About the authors

David Mansfield is a specialist on development in a drugs environment who has spent 15 years working in coca- and opium-producing countries, with over eight years’ experience conducting research into the role of opium in rural livelihood strategies in Afghanistan.

Adam Pain has worked on issues of rural livelihoods in the Himalayan region for the last 15 years. He is a research fellow at the School of Development Studies, University of East Anglia, UK, and visiting professor of rural development at the Department of Urban and Rural Development,
Swedish University of Agricultural Science, Uppsala.

“Opium Poppy Eradication: How to raise risk when there is nothing to lose?” is available for download at
http://www.areu.org.af/index.php?option=com_docman&Itemid=&task=doc_download&gid=42
6. Hard copies are available free of charge from the AREU office in Kabul: Flower St (Corner of
St 2), Shahr-i-Naw, Kabul.
Contact
Anja Havedal
Communications Editor
+93 (0) 799 192646
[email protected]
About AREU

The Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit (AREU) is an independent research organisation that conducts and facilitates action-oriented research and learning aimed at informing and influencing policy and practice. AREU also actively promotes a culture of research and learning by strengthening analytical capacity in Afghanistan and by creating opportunities for analysis
and debate. As an independent research organisation headquartered in Afghanistan, AREU works to ensure that its findings are relevant and inform and influence the process of change taking place on the ground. Fundamental to AREU’s vision is that its work should improve
Afghan lives. AREU was established by the assistance community working in Afghanistan and has a board of directors with equal representation from donors, UN and other multilateral agencies, and nongovernmental
organisations (NGOs). Current funding is provided by the European Commission
(EC), the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA), the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), Stichting Vluchteling and the governments of the United Kingdom, Canada, Denmark (DANIDA), Norway, Switzerland and Sweden.



PUBLICATIONS FROM AREU

All publications are available for download at www.areu.org.af, or in
hardcopy from the AREU office in Kabul.

This list is current as of 1 July 2007.

June 2007 To Return or to Remain: The Dilemma of Second-Generation
Afghans in Pakistan, by Mamiko Saito and Pamela Hunte

June 2007 Water Management, Livestock and the Opium Economy: The Spread
of Opium Poppy Cultivation in Balkh, by Adam Pain

May 2007 Water Management, Livestock and the Opium Economy: Livestock
Feed and Products, by Anthony Fitzherbert

May 2007 Water Management, Livestock and the Opium Economy: The
Performance of Community Water Management Systems, by
Jonathan L. Lee

and many more on the subject of alternative livelihoods in Afghanistan

charas cultivation under licence anyone?
 
Last edited:

ngakpa

Active member
Veteran
Counter Narcotics strategy a failure says Afghan CN Minister

Counter Narcotics strategy a failure says Afghan CN Minister

Failings in war on Afghan drugs
By Alastair Leithead
BBC News, Kabul
27th August 2007


charas production and sale under central government license - anyone?

"In security we have failed, in the drug issue we have failed. We have not done a good job in Helmand. This year we must change our strategy on how to work to handle security and tackle the poppy in Helmand province."
General Khodaidad, Afghan Minister for Counter Narcotics


The United Nations says opium production in Afghanistan has "soared to frightening record levels" with an increase on last year of more than a third.

The UN Office on Drugs and Crime report says the amount of opium produced has doubled in the last two years, and that Helmand province is now the biggest single drug producing area in the world - surpassing whole countries.

Despite billions of dollars of aid and tens of thousands of international troops, the 193,000 hectares of opium poppies grown in Afghanistan this year are now responsible for almost all the world's opiates, according to the UN report.

"The results are very bad, terrifyingly bad," said Antonio Maria Costa, the head of UN Office on Drugs and Crime.

Cultivation was at a historic level, he said, pointing out that the total yield was up 34% because the weather had made the poppies more productive.


'Serious picture'

But despite the overall increase, twice as many provinces are now drug-free in northern and central Afghanistan, and the report says growing opium poppies is now closely linked to the insurgency and the instability in the south.

The UN report links the Taleban to the increase in opiate production.

The figures come as a major setback for British efforts to reduce the amount of opium poppies grown in Afghanistan - the raw materials for most of the UK and Europe's heroin.

They are the lead nation fighting the war against drug growers and traffickers.

The British ambassador, Sir Sherard Cowper-Coles, said: "It paints a very serious picture and we are deeply concerned.

"The drugs problem is a symptom of a deeper disease and as we tackle instability, tackle disorder and the insurgency, we are facing some very big challenges on all those fronts, but as we tackle them we will see poppy production go down.

"The overall conclusion is that there are no magic solutions, no silver bullets, and that this requires patience. As experience in Pakistan or Thailand shows, it takes 15 or 20 years to squeeze a cancer like this out of a society as debilitated as Afghanistan's is after 30 years of war," he said.

The report recommends more determined efforts to bring security, urging the government to get tough on corruption which it says is driving the drugs trade.

It lists poor governance, a weak judiciary and failing eradication programmes as contributing factors.

For another year the eradication efforts were hampered not just by corruption in the national government, but also by corruption at local levels.

'Counter-drugs policy'

Arguments have been put forward for a change of strategy - one campaign group is trying to pilot programmes to legalise drug production, and the American Ambassador, Bill Wood, believes aerial spraying could make a huge impact.

"Yes, it's still my view," he said. "We all agree illicit narcotics are a cancer and as consulting physicians, some emphasise radiation therapy, some surgery. I'm a surgery man myself, but we all agree we have to cut the cancer out and we are committed to a much more robust effort this year.

"Alternative livelihood for the farmers is one element, the second element is interdiction and the third is eradication. All three of those elements are necessary for a counter-drugs policy."

And emphasis is being placed on the Afghan government to put its house in order and crack down on the drugs lords.

The UN says it has given a list of names, and the British government has funded a high-security prison for the "Mr Bigs", but still there is little progress.

The acting Minister for Counter Narcotics, General Khodaidad, says these targets will be pursued, but there is little evidence on the ground that this is happening, with some in the government alleged to have links with the traffickers, while the judiciary is still struggling to keep up.

"Unfortunately we have failed," Gen Khodaidad said.

"In security we have failed, in the drug issue we have failed. We have not done a good job in Helmand. This year we must change our strategy on how to work to handle security and tackle the poppy in Helmand province."
 
Last edited:

Yarkand

Active member
Hashish Drug ban divides militants By Ismail Khan PESHAWAR, March 20:

With their long flowing hair, beards and boots, they could resemble the hippies of yesteryears. Except that these hippies from the wild western borderland of Pakistan are gun-toting, rocket-carrying militants ready to kill or be killed. The hippies of the 60s were pacifists but these turban-wearing, young tribal Taliban are as wild as their looks would suggest. But one thing they have in common ? a love for hashish. Welcome to the restive South Waziristan, the heartland of the tribal militants, where a group of the local Taliban have not only taken up arms against the government but also turned their guns against their own ilk for threatening to close down hashish shops. They have done so in Karikot, Azam Warsak, Shah Alam, Raghzai Ghwakhwa, Spin Tanai and Dabkot. Defiance of their attempts has come not from the owners or operators of the shops, but from some of the Taliban?s own ranks. A militant commander, Ghulam Jan, recently warned hashish shop owners to close down their business or face punishment as Islam prohibited the use and sale of drugs. Worried, the shop owners gathered to ponder over the situation and find a remedy. They were pleasantly surprised to find that they were not alone. Soon a group of about 200 hashish-loving Taliban gathered and nominated their own commander, Ilyas, to fend off pressure against the drug, according to locals. An official report, however, put the figure at more than 500.






















 
Top